Thank you Tim for all your books. your writing has helped me grow not only
as a person but also as a writer.
Brian macken <Macken@SVA.com>
NY, NY USA - Wednesday, December 31, 1997 at 00:03:16 (CST)
I'm doing a comparative essay between "The Things They Carried"
and " Going After Cacciato " I'd appreciate any help anyone could give me.
Elizabeth Shinn <Shizlin@aol.com>
Philadelphia, PA USA - Friday, December 26, 1997 at 11:53:12 (CST)
I am currently preparing a Doctoral thesis on the work of Tim O'Brien. I
believe "Going After Cacciato" to be a literary masterpiece. I welcome
discussion of Mr O'Brien's work with anyone willing to contact me. If Tim O'Brien reads
this, I thank you for everything I have gained from your work.
Lynn Wharton <lynn.wharton@virgin.net>
England - Friday, December 26, 1997 at 08:50:10 (CST)
I was with the 11th about 2 years before you. I got an early out to go to
school. My first degree was in jernalism, not to write a book, it was just easy. I was the
genious in the group, the rest of my friends got degrees in camp management. What we were
best at was drinking beer, chasing girlsand playing baseball and flagfootball. The ones
that were the most fun died young,we played hard. I have never figured out how or why I
have lived so long. The book I read was "The things they Carried". It brought
back some memories that I have long forgotten. I like to leave the forgotten. I still stay
in touch with 4-5 of the men on our platoon. We dont see very much of each other, buy we
are still good friends. Whenever I go back to Chicago, we all get together. We meet in a
bar on the south side of chicago and tell lies all night. I will look at another of your
books, but I really don't like the subject. Thanks, Mike Collins
Mike Collins <talk400000 aol>
Chester, VA USA - Friday, December 19, 1997 at 22:41:11 (CST)
I have placed a link to this Page in my Vietnam War Memorial, the purpose
of which is of course to honor the Men and Woment that had served in Vietnam. Greetings,
Cecilio E. Gracias, President, C G Enterprises Inc. 12/18/97
Cecilio E. Gracias <gracias@ibm.net>
Guilderland, NY USA - Thursday, December 18, 1997 at 18:35:48 (CST)
I was a FO with D. Co. 4/21 INF, 11 LIB for 6 months and later a FDO with
D. Btry. 6/11 Arty, 11 LIB for 6 months from Mar. 68 to Mar. 69 in the Americal Div. Glad
you made it home safely.
Walter H. Haltom III <whaltom@nortel.com>
Carrollton, TX USA - Tuesday, December 16, 1997 at 14:49:57 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, I should not be surprised that in this day and age there
would be a web site devoted to you and your work. Now, even years after the war we as a
nation are still dealing with its effects. We deal with it through writing, through music,
and through our actions. I am surprised that I had not thought to look you up on the net
much sooner since my honors mentorship project was inspired by "The Things They
Carried." Currently I am a student at Tidewater Community College in Chesapeake, VA,
and for my project I will be writing about the literature inspired by the war, yours
inparticular, and the effects of the war on the generation of men and women, such as
myself, who may have lost a mother or a fathers in the war. As a former Marine, I am
sometimes asked why I decided to enlist in the Corps concidering my own father was killed
in Viet Nam. I often wonder about that myself, and also about other choices I have made in
life. Hopefully, I will not do a disservice to your work. Thank you for sharing your ideas
with those of us who have an appreciation for it.
William O. Jones II <wm_o_jones@hotmail.com>
Norfolk, VA USA - Friday, December 12, 1997 at 10:33:00 (CST)
Met O'Brien at a reading last year. Asked him then if he had read Ivan
Klima. He hadn't. Still think he should. They're a lot alike.
MOOT <wmoot@aol.com>
rochester, ny USA - Thursday, December 11, 1997 at 22:07:36 (CST)
I always wanted to write a book about my experiences in Nam, but can't
handle digging into the goary details. I'm working on my images for the 1st. time since
1970, & it's not easy. I hope this is all worth it.
Bob Heurung <nstar@cloudnet.com>
St.Joseph, MN USA - Thursday, December 04, 1997 at 08:45:10 (CST)
I recently read "The Man I killed" and am in the process of
doing a multimedia presentaion on a compilation of your works for my American Lit. class.
I must admit that I do not enjoy reading, however, your style and attention to detail has
got me a little excited over your works. Excellent writing!
Brad Hounshell <bradly@proaxis.com>
Albany, OR USA - Thursday, December 04, 1997 at 01:36:12 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, I am in the midst of writing a paper of The Things They
Carried for my American Lit class and I would like to thank you for writing what is
possibly the first enjoyable book I've read for school. My father served two tours in
Vietnam and died from cancer caused by Agent Orange when I was seven, I never really knew
what it was like there, but thanks to you I think I now have an idea.
Devin Landin <dlandin@hotmail.com>
Yorktown, NY USA - Wednesday, December 03, 1997 at 11:13:01 (CST)
Tim O'Brien is the greatest author who ever picked up a pen.
Bryan Vincent <BTVincen@mail.snu.edu>
Bethany, OK USA - Monday, December 01, 1997 at 20:57:28 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, I have read your books for English courses at my college and
I want to thank you for writng absolutely brilliant matterial. Everything of yours which I
have read has had me hooked since page one. Keep up the outstanding work.
Jef Hitsman <jhitsman>
Ashland, Oh USA - Saturday, November 29, 1997 at 16:36:35 (CST)
Dear Mr. O'Brien, I know not what one might need to say to grab the
attention of your eyes. The eloquence that must accompany. However, I wish to convey to
you my deepest sympathies, your telling saga's illuminate the written word with such
sorrow, and pain. Yet, for some reason I seem to associate pain and sorrow with depth of
emotion. Why I don't know. Anyway thank you for your words and your tales; true of false.
And if-I doub't I'll get a reply, Isay this more to those who read it than you yourself--
seeing as you must have to peruse hundreds of letters. but thanks none the less. Thanks
Chris.
Christopher Gehrke <Cphado@yahoo.com>
Minneapolis, Mn USA - Friday, November 28, 1997 at 20:46:41 (CST)
So long ago. And yet so near. Sorrow -- "If it is cured by anything
less than death, the chances are it was not true sorrow." Islands In The Stream-- E.
Hemmingway
Paul Stephen Tedeschi <writor@aol.com>
ma USA - Friday, November 28, 1997 at 19:37:41 (CST)
I learn literature translation from English into Japansese and train my
writing ability. Someday I want to be able to write enough Japanese to translate your
works.
Atsushi Kurowa <fwiv5062@mb.infoweb.ne.jp>
Tsuchiura, Ibaraki Japan - Wednesday, November 26, 1997 at 23:11:17 (CST)
It's great to see a site dedicated to Tim O'brien. I was exposed to his
work first in the form of "Cacciatto," a couple of years back in a great class
at Montclair State University. I have since read everything except "Northern
Lights" which I am trying to find. O'briens work is as important as it is
entertaining, and I recommend it to anyone. Thanks.
Patrick Moore <brundle@eclipse.net>
NJ USA - Wednesday, November 26, 1997 at 17:24:26 (CST)
Dear Mr.o`Brien, My name is Walter Janes and I live in New
Brunswick,Canada. I received your book "The Things They Carried" for Christmas
last year and I must tell you that out off all the stories I`ve read on the Vietnam War
these stories made the hair on my neck stand up. I was brought up in the U.S. during the
war and watched every night while the pictures were sent back to all of our TV`s. I was a
bit too young to really understand what was going on but when I got to High School the
reality of the situation set in. I have an older brother, who is Canadian, and he served
off the coast of Vietnam on board the aircraft carrier U.S.S.Intrepid. I`am trying to find
some info on Canadians who served in Vietnam and was thinking of putting together a
Documentry on this subject if it has not been done as of yet. Thanks for taking the time
to read this and Good Luck in your future. Walter A. Janes
Walter Janes <boggle@nb.sympatico.ca>
Saint John, N.B. Canada - Tuesday, November 25, 1997 at 09:00:28 (CST)
I can't believe that "The Things They Carried" was fiction after
reading it.
Matthew Levien <Mlevien@adnc.com>
San Diego, CA USA - Monday, November 24, 1997 at 19:26:53 (CST)
I FELT THAT THE THINGS THEY CARRIED WAS A TRUE DEPICTION OF THE VIETNAM
WAR. HE SHOWED BOTH SIDES, THE GOOD AND THE BAD. MOST PEOPLE ONLY KNOW ONE SIDE. HE PUTS
EVERYTHING HE HAS INTO THIS BOOK.
Edward Wilson <EDNSONYA@PRODIGY.NET>
OK USA - Saturday, November 22, 1997 at 10:20:58 (CST)
Incredible. Every word. I have been facinated by the entire Viet Nam
experience since I was a child. The impact you left on us as you read (recited) "The
Man I Killed" at Ohio State in 1994(?) will forever be with us. Will forever haunt
us. Thank you.
Patrick F. Clifford
Columbus, OH USA - Friday, November 21, 1997 at 22:00:50 (CST)
I really like this page, but that's not why I'm signing the guestbook.
About one year ago I read 'If I die in a combat zone' for my graduation of what you'd call
'Highschool'. Anyway, I really loved it and wish to thank Tim O'Brien just for writing
this book. So Tim, if you're ever to read this, great work!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Erik van Nieuwburg <i60004@stuhi.ptf.hwb.nl>
Zevenbergen, The Netherlands - Friday, November 14, 1997 at 09:44:05 (CST)
Hello, Enjoyed the article about Tim O'Brien in War, Literature and the
Arts. I published a short story there in the same issue. I teach at Mesa State College.
For my next Compostion course I plan on using THE THINGS THEY CARRIED, among others to
teach Vietnam literature. Anybody have suggestions. I am a veteran of the 101st in Phu Bai
-- 1969 to 1970. So long, Al
Allen Learst <alearst@mesa5.mesa.colorado.edu>
Grand Junction, CO USA - Thursday, November 13, 1997 at 15:35:25 (CST)
I had to read "The things they carried" for my English
composition class and liked it a lot. As the son of a Vietnam veteran, it meant something
more to me as well. Thank you.
Rob Faber <rfaber@creighton.edu>
Omaha, NE USA - Thursday, November 13, 1997 at 12:59:09 (CST)
I thought that "The Things They Carried" was one of the most
thought provoking and greatest books I have ever read. I look forward to hearing Mr.
O'Brien give a talk here and reading the rest of his novels.
Robert C Pruyne Jr. <rpruyne@ecs.umass.edu>
Amherst, Ma USA - Wednesday, November 12, 1997 at 20:56:24 (CST)
I have read all the books you've written--fine books. In fact, I may write
my master's thesis on your works (sorry). It will either be you or Shakespeare, so you are
in good company. I listened to a reading you gave in Spokane, Washington a while ago. I am
eagerly looking forward to the completing of the nascent work you read to us. I recall an
interesting observation regarding Woody Allen's stories being among America's best, which
I have said for years. It was nice to have corroboration. Thanks for all you do.
Paul Vanek <vanekp@mailhost.sd02.k12.id.us>
Boise, ID USA - Wednesday, November 12, 1997 at 15:28:42 (CST)
Tim was a guest of Radford University in '94. I'll never forget his visit.
I was a student under Tim Poland, enrolled in his "War and Pieces" class. Tim
(O'brien) also gave a reading at Heth Hall. Someone is going to have to really show me
something in order to out-do "The Things They Carried." Here's to all who
believe in the power of the story.
Curt Alderson <venusno2@juno.com>
Roanoke, VA USA - Wednesday, November 12, 1997 at 11:05:32 (CST)
Hi! I wanted to let you know that I have included a link to the Tim
O'Brien site on the Pages, Polls and Puns page of my web site, garbl's The Near Side. My
site was recently named No. 1 in a Top 10 listing of member sites on The Globe. I hope
that people visiting my site find their way to yours. Please write me if you have
questions or comments! Thanks! Gary Also, here's another web site of mine that might
interest you, Garbl's Writing Resources On Line:
http://www.netcom.com/~garbl1/writing.html
Gary B. Larson <garbltoo@ix.netcom.com>
Seattle, WA USA - Tuesday, November 11, 1997 at 16:30:47 (CST)
Mr. O'Brian, I'm a vet, served in special services in field hospitals and
basecamps. I'm putting together a non-fiction piece on books that men and women might have
read while in Vietnam and might remember the book. I had the pleasure of meeting Norman
Mailer a few weeks back( I'm The Program Director for The Learning Annex in New York.) He
told me how he carried two books with him all through the Pacific, and how he read them
every chance he got. Was there a book, or books you read while being in Vietnam that you
can remember now? Thanks Tom Dwyer
tom dwyer <tdwyer @easyway.net>
jersey city, nj USA - Sunday, November 09, 1997 at 14:37:10 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, in my junior year of high school, I chose to write my term
paper on two of your novels, If I Die in a Combat Zone, and Going After Cacciato, after
reading a brief description of your works. Later, I also read The Things They Carried.
Your novels are captivating no matter how many times I read them. Thank you.
Sara Nakai <sdnst4+@pitt.edu>
New Castle, DE USA - Saturday, November 08, 1997 at 14:52:43 (CST)
The things they carried is a great book. My history teacher assigned us
that at first we thought it would be boring, but then after reading the book it was
interesting. Good Job!
SHEYLA AUCAR <TUDOS@HOTMAIL.COM>
SAN FRANCISCO, CA USA - Thursday, November 06, 1997 at 14:05:22 (CST)
Your service and suffering in Vietnam is deeply appreciated,all else pales
in comparison. Allen Austin
<allena@tcoe.k12.ca.us>
Porterville, CA USA - Tuesday, November 04, 1997 at 17:45:28 (CST)
Tim, Loved your Vietnam books and Lake of the Woods. Also grew up in a
small city in southern MN and was in the Army and RVN 69-70.
Dennis L. Jerome <dukej@hotmail.com>
Grand Rapids, MN USA - Tuesday, November 04, 1997 at 10:55:13 (CST)
The Things They Carried was a really good book. I am so glad that we got
to read this in school. It relly made me feel like I was there, experiencing this with
you.
Stephanie Fugate <sfd2125@saintjoe.edu>
Renesselear, IN USA - Monday, November 03, 1997 at 23:23:35 (CST)
Mr O'Brien, My name is Nina Craig and I just mailed a letter to you c/o
penguin.I hope that it eventually gets to you. In my Intro to fiction class at University
of Houston we read THE THINGS THEY CARRIED. It was an amazing book, the best I've ever
read. I ran to the book store and bought three more of your novels,IF I DIE IN A COMBAT
ZONE,NORTHERN LIGHTS,and GOING AFTER CACCIATO. I can't express to you how moved I was by
your work.
Nina Craig <ncraig@bayou.uh.edu>
houston, TX USA - Thursday, October 30, 1997 at 09:46:02 (CST)
Keep the great work.
SGT Stephen D. Slaughter <fox@evansville.net>
Henderson, Ky USA - Tuesday, October 28, 1997 at 00:44:19 (CST)
As I just finnished "The Things They Carried", I've got to tell
everyone that it was the best book I've ever read. I've become a Tim O'Brien fan!
Robert Aspfors <raspfors@hem.passagen.se>
Stockholm, Sweden - Sunday, October 26, 1997 at 09:39:58 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, Last year in my freshmen English class I read "How to
Tell a True War Story" ever since that class I have enjoyed many of your works. I
never thought I could enjoy stories of war or even the Vietnam war for that matter. My
oldest brother always read novels about wars and so I shared your books with him and he
really enjoyed them. I'd like to thank my english professor (langw@post.uwstout.edu) for
introducing me to your books and short stories. And thanks to you for sparking my interest
in reading for pleasure again. I used to read all the time but since I started college I
haven't had time but now I make time to read.
Christie Brandt <brandtc@post.uwstout.edu>
menomonie, we USA - Wednesday, October 22, 1997 at 19:55:45 (CDT)
Tim I am 35 years old and I have never been a reader. I used to drive
trucks coast to coast till I got sick and can't do it. I am in college now (Boise State
University) one of my english assignments was to read your book (The Things They Carried).
I really enjoied the book. We now have to write an essay for class and use some of the
style in our writing that you did. I would like to write something about the war or about
the solders. I have never been in war or in the militery, but I grew up during the Nam
war. I had relitives there who have all returned and I my dad had friends there as well.
Some of witch did not return. If there any help you can give me please E-mail me back.
Thank You and I look foward to reading more of your books.
William S. Hancock Jr. <billhanjr@worldnet.att.net>
Eagle, Id USA - Wednesday, October 22, 1997 at 00:16:43 (CDT)
Hi Tim. This is Van. I love the books you wrote, especially, "If I
die in a combat zone" . It's one of the greatest book I've ever read. ... In the lake
of the wood is also a great book... I just have a question for you, If you weren't in Nam,
How would you understand the feelings of guys who suffered in Nam ?How would you know the
feeling of Lt. Calley when Calley first saw the VC kill his buddy ?
van Nguyen <vannguyen@aol.com>
The Valley, MA USA - Tuesday, October 21, 1997 at 14:45:55 (CDT)
in november, i will be leading a book discussion on o'brien's IN THE LAKE
OF THE WOODS. i have become a real o'brien fan. started with IN THE LAKE and went on to
THE THINGS THEY CARRIED. still reading CACIATTO. what a great concept: walking from viet
nam to paris. the scenes in the tunnels in laos are inspired.
Pat <Patsy31748@aol.com>
Penfield, NY USA - Tuesday, October 14, 1997 at 20:12:37 (CDT)
I am currently undertaking a study on Vietnam literature and journalism
for my final year at University. Tim O'Brien's "If I die in a combat zone"
inspired me to study this topic. Having been leant the book by a friend in my first year
of study, the impact it made on me has fulled my desire to study Vietnam and it's
literature. I would be more than delighted to speak to anyone on any topic concerning
Vietnam particularly any Veterans who have opinions on the literature that came out of
Vietnam.
Paula Ellard <allat51@foobar.co.uk>
Leicester, Britain - Saturday, October 11, 1997 at 09:15:54 (CDT)
After reading his book, If I Die in a Combat Zone, I've come to love Tim
O'Brien and all of his books!
Trisha Hoelscher
Wall, TX USA - Wednesday, October 08, 1997 at 08:39:56 (CDT)
I am curently reading The Things They Carried. I love it.
Drew Lustman <Standbyme2>
New Haven, ct USA - Thursday, October 02, 1997 at 16:35:37 (CDT)
Finding O'Brien's canon has been a true gold mine for discussion and
speculation. I have taught "Cacciato" at both the high school and the college
level for the past six years. It continues to be one of the best pieces of my curriculum.
Together my students and I attempt to "order the facts"; we "concentrate
and look closer"; we come "to learn and to understand"; we attempt not to
be merely tourists. In the concentrating, the ordering, and the understanding a problem
arises: the problem is Rudy Chassler, his death broke the quiet of the August
"Pick-up Games"; he holds the plastic drip bottle for Bernie Lynn; he smiles in
Chinook just before Jim Pederson is killed by not so friendly fire; he appears to be in
too many places; he appears to be alive after he has been reported to have died. Can
anyone help me out? My concentration and my ordering have have let me down. Waiting...
James Cross <jcross@bosco>
Bellflower, CA USA - Tuesday, September 30, 1997 at 15:32:26 (CDT)
Teaching many of O'Brien's dreaming wakes/waking dreams to talented high
school seniors brings a thrilling sense of...proximity, immediacy , into the classroom.
But, we're not so good at internet research. We're desperately seeking a copy of "The
Viet Nam in Me" from the NYT but remained stumped. Any suggestions? yours Jillian
Jill Simmons <Ljilly28@Aol.com>
New Haven, CT USA - Saturday, September 27, 1997 at 09:08:26 (CDT)
I checked out your site and injoyed my stay.
Jim Dillon Sr <jdillon@softwareplus.net>
Gore, OK USA - Thursday, September 25, 1997 at 20:08:42 (CDT)
I read The Things They Carried (the collection, not just the story) during
my first year of college in a creative writing class. I graduated with a Creative Writing
degree a few months ago and still yours is a book I keep going back to. Fantastic and
splendid and so clearly written it is devestating. The writing is inspirational and the
stories are valuable lessons. Thank you very much.
Kevin W. Koperski <koperski@mindspring.com>
Seattle, WA USA - Wednesday, September 24, 1997 at 22:35:46 (CDT)
Thank you!
Pia Christine Heyn <pwbrus1@ukcc.uky.edu>
Lexington, KY USA - Wednesday, September 24, 1997 at 09:25:57 (CDT)
Tim O'Brien, I was at the College of Wooster when you were a resident
writer. I enjoyed the class discussions you took part in, and I have become a captive of
"The Things They Carried" ever since. I am teaching it now, and the book never
seems to lose its affect. The students have a hard time believing it is FICTION.
Mark C. Hoven <mhoven@rocketmail.com>
Rome, Ga USA - Friday, September 19, 1997 at 09:29:46 (CDT)
Tim O'Brien, I loved your short story in the English 2 high school books
it was great. It was titled "Where Have You Gone, Charming Billy?" You got me
interested in the Vietnam War. I am going to read more of your books. Thanks a lot!
Erica Dial
Marion, IL USA - Thursday, September 18, 1997 at 22:43:51 (CDT)
Hi. I'm a Belgian univ-student who decided to do his final project on Tim
O'Brien's The Things They Carried, one of the finest 'novels' I've ever read. If any-one
can help me find interesting info about this book or its author, please contact me.
Thanks.
Wattez Ludo <ludo.wattez@student.kuleuven.ac.be>
Leuven, Belgium - Wednesday, September 17, 1997 at 09:25:48 (CDT)
Dear Tim, Thank you for your wonderful books. They have opened many
people's lives to the truth in Vietnam. More than that, you are an extremely talented
writer and are one of my favorite writers. Thank you for giving me that sick feeling when
I saw the baby water buffalo get shot, the necklace of human tongues, the star-shaped eye.
I never realized how insensitive many people are to the war and its veterans.Best of
Wishes to You,Lesley
Lesley Trupiano <Lennon7>
Los Angeles, CA USA - Tuesday, September 16, 1997 at 21:48:36 (CDT)
I love your work. I recived you as an author for a research paper in my AP
English class and have read all your books.
Nathan Drashner
Boise, ID USA - Tuesday, September 16, 1997 at 11:47:43 (CDT)
Love the O'Brien site. I am a huge fan of his work although I have not had
the opportunity to read *In the Lake of the Woods* yet.I wrote a paper on *The Things They
Carried* last semster for a 300 level English class. More specifically, it is about the
chapter, The Man I Killed. Would you want it to post? Let me know.Sean
Sean Bevan <bevans1@alpha.lasalle.edu>
Philadelphia, PA USA - Monday, September 15, 1997 at 22:29:01 (CDT)
Tim, I am studing your book, In The Lake of The Woods in my final year
(year 12) at school, and I would just like to say how great it is to study and pick up on
all the finer details in the story. But I'm hanging out to know whether you wrote the
story, actually with an answer to "What happened to Kathy?" in your mind. There
are so many alternatives and I want to know which one, if there is one, do you think is
the answer. Thanks, a great book. Adam.
Adam Waycott <waycotts@cnl.com.au>
Yarrawonga, Vic Australia - Monday, September 08, 1997 at 05:53:33 (CDT)
Thanks for making today's youth stop and reflect on a time too precious
and costly to overlook. As an Am Lit teacher I know how important your words are to
putting the pieces together for them--- and me.
Doc
USA - Thursday, September 04, 1997 at 14:02:24 (CDT)
ANYBODY who would like to know all about the Vietnam War should read your
books, Tim. Especially "The Things They Carried." Being a Vietnam Veteran
(hospital corpsman) myself, I can vouch for the authenticity of your writing. In fact, i'm
a writer of poems, strictly devoted to events of the Vietnam War. Your books shine
through, in an otherwise dismal plateau of books pertaining to Vietnam. I thank you for
your words. Please....write more.
Robert H. Dirr Jr. <Lynn-Bob@msn.com>
Cincinnati, Oh USA - Monday, September 01, 1997 at 10:12:47 (CDT)
Read your book "If I die in a Combat Zone" in Mr Steve Potts
vietnam history class last quarter. It was great! very realistic.I was a Wave (Navy)
during Vietnam, stationed on a base in Texas that trained pilots so took the class and
learned the truth about the war.I am looking forward to reading your other books.Check out
my homepage http://www.angelfire.com/mn/WavesNational/index.html
Dee Sabin <pandora@uslink.com>
Hibbing, Mn USA - Friday, August 29, 1997 at 17:59:41 (CDT)
Mr. O'Brien, I have approached your work from the aspect of awriter, not a
vet - I'm a college student now. Even though inmy life I have not faced anything that
nearly compares withyour experiencs, your work has influenced me greatly. Yourwords have
an incredible ring of truth to them, and even thoughI can tell from your tremendous amount
of craft the care which you put into your stories, they read as if you were in the room
with me.Your work has transcended the vietnam experience. Yourstories, especially
"The Things They Carried", althoyugh I also havea special connection with
"In the Lake of the Woods", tellof human truths; human failures and triumphs.
Your stuff hastruly widened my view of this species we're a part of. It'sbeen a great
pleasure reading your work, and I'm anxiouslyawaiting new stuff. Take care.
Ben Hickernell <bhickern@haverford.edu>
baltimore, md USA - Friday, August 29, 1997 at 01:39:36 (CDT)
Tim you must have jumped in an out of my skin!!? I was there I corp 6th
11th Arty San Juan hill, came in 11-6-69 to 10-20th something 1970, out of service March
10th 71 FT. Riley KS. I have 5 works of art Chicago National Vietnam Veterans Musuem. Lost
a very good friend in nam like so many. He was Dean Borrousch a big farm kid from the
upper part of Michigan (Hawks). Never should have been in military, so many stories, yours
is so much similar to my own, I can't go on. Best wishes, Bro.
Mike Gottschalk <mtschalk@tir.com>
Lapeer, Mi USA - Thursday, August 28, 1997 at 12:44:08 (CDT)
Mr. O'Brien,I am currently involved in an Honors Project at the University
of North Carolina at Wilmington, and I have chosen your work asmy topic. After being
exposed first to your short stories, and then your novels, I have found your writing to be
riveting and quite moving. It is my hope to continue working with literature from this
moment in our nation's history, as it is filled with many disturbing issues that haunt us
as a nation even today.I look forward to reading more about you, and from you.Thank you
for listening to the writer within and sharing yourthoughts. If you have not inspired
anyone else, you have inspired me.Sincerely,Donna Packer
Donna Packer <skinla19@mail.idt.net>
wilmington, nc USA - Thursday, August 21, 1997 at 20:07:53 (CDT)
Thanks, Tim. I finally found an author I can really
understand. In The Things They Carried, I was there, looking through your eyes. I finally
came to understand my own place in that page of history. I was a CO, or I-O. Not popular.
Survivor's guilt and all that. You helped me put it in perspective. About time. I'm 52.
Someday we will meet. Thanks again.
CHUCK WAGNER <wagnerb@destinywagnerb@destiny.esd105.wednet.edu>
Selah, WA USA - Friday, July 18, 1997 at 18:41:30 (CDT)
Am patiently waiting for you next work, Mr. O'Brien.
Wait, did I say patiently? Hell, when can I look forward to another fine piece of writing?
It seems I am comparing the work of all other writers to you, which is foolish. Yet, how I
have enjoyed all your books. Keep all of us posted as to what might be up and coming.
Robert
Robert Spaet <spaet@planet.net>
Budd Lake, NJ USA - Wednesday, July 09, 1997 at 18:59:57 (CDT)
I've been teaching THE THINGS THEY CARRIED for a few
years in an American Literature survey at Bucks County Community College---as many times
as I have read it, I am always stunned, and find more and more each time I reread it. Do
you do reading tours and do you get to the Greater Philadelphia area. I'd love to arrange
to have you read at the College.
Michael Pilz <jp9057@p3.net OR
jp9057@aol.com>
USA - Saturday, July 05, 1997 at 11:06:06 (CDT)
I think it is wonderful that Tim O'brien has his own
page. I'm doing some research and stumbled accross it.
Roberto A. Moran <RMoran2345@aol.com>
San Pedro, CA USA - Monday, June 30, 1997 at 18:05:23 (CDT)
Tim, Glad to see you on the web....I was Ben
Anderson's recon platoon leader from Nov. 68 until he went to Alpha in Jan. 69. Your first
book brought back a lot of memories...LTC. Barnes and Pinkville to name a couple. Take
care and I'll try to write more later....ever think of compiling a historical record of
our unit? I'd love to see you do it! Sincerely, Jess Helms (former 1Lt,5/46)
Jesse L. Helms, Jr. <JHelms@aol.com>
Greenville, SC USA - Wednesday, June 04, 1997 at 13:47:09 (CDT)
Met you at Ind. Univ. and am returning to Quang Ngai
as you suggested. My only question is do we still operate the steam and creams there? 2
days after you left I met a neighbor of yours in Minn. Is everything she says about you
true? Peace, Love and the right to go home
Blue <MilinCR@aol.com>
Bloomington, In USA - Thursday, May 22, 1997 at 20:59:42 (CDT)
Dia duit! Your novel Lake/Wood is one available for
study by Year 12 (seniors) students n Victoria for 1998: i am currently working on a study
guide for publication - this is the first of your work i have read, primary interest is
poetry - but lake/wood grabbed me - fulfils robert Graves' prescription for a good poem -
amkes the hair stand on end when shaving! As I get into the writing, I'll try to find ways
of communicating ideas - you may be able to respond, hopefully. Hope you can come to
Australia one day. Alternative email address is "geelongh@gsat.edu.au" if you
can't get through to me at home. Edward Reilly MA English Department Geelogn High School
Edward Reilly <ejreily@deakin.edu.au>
Geelong, Victoria Australia - Thursday, May 22, 1997 at 00:22:14 (CDT)
Dear Mr. Obrien, I recently read The Things They
Carried for a class I am taking about America and Vietnam. It shook me to the core. your
"story truth" has given me new purpose in my pursuit of understanding the war,
its effects, and its meaning. When I read about the Red River, I thought of myself about 6
years ago, when I was concerned that if the War against Iraq went on for too long, I would
be drafted into service. I know now that whether or not the book is truth or lies does not
matter. Things happen and people feel-- all we can try to do is help convey that feeling
sensation to others, then they can understand, at least in part, the turth of any given
event. Thank you for your work, it is truly inspiring! Adam Chose Gustavus Adolphus
College.
Adam Chose <achose@gac.edu>
St. Peter, MN USA - Thursday, May 08, 1997 at 20:55:56 (CDT)
Mr. O'Brien, I'm 16 and a junior at Oakton High
School, (Fairfax County, Virginia). My English assignment is to assume your identity and
write a letter to Norman Mailer whose identity is assigned to a different classmate. I am
to write a letter to "Norman Mailer" as you and write about what we have in
common. My English teacher, Mr. Klein, gave me an article written by you, "The
Vietnam In Me", for the New York Times Magazine in 1994. At first, I did not
understand why I had to read this article about a war that I really had no interest in. I
started reading this and realized right away why I was given this assignment. Needless to
say, I was amazed and embarrassed to learn that I knew so little about this war and how it
affected the people who fought it. I think that I appreciate the fact that my Father had
to go to Vietnam when he was only three years older than I am. My dad found your home
page, which allowed me to learn even more about you. I just wanted to leave this message
and let you know how much I respect you and your writing. Sincerely, Michelle
Michelle King <GoodyGoodi@aol.com>
Herndon, VA USA - Wednesday, May 07, 1997 at 21:44:06 (CDT)
Dear Mr. O'Brien: indefinitely, it is intersting
what technology can accomplish these days; with the click of the button, I am actually
performing cyber communications with one of the most prominent American writers of our
days. As a junior in high-school, I've always been intrigued by the dehumanization of war,
and I think your book "The Things They Carried" really affected me. By and by, I
am currently filing up to do an indepth author report about you, and I am amazed by the
things you've accomplished!
Elaine Yang
Pebble Beach, CA USA - Wednesday, May 07, 1997 at 11:23:50 (CDT)
I really enjoyed reading The Things They Carried. A
truely great book about the Vietnam War even though I do not really think it is about the
war. Of course it is about the war but not only. I have read it twice all ready and I will
probably read it again. Thank you!
Malin Wennerlund <mp.wennerlund@swipnet.se>
Stockholm, Sweden - Sunday, May 04, 1997 at 05:41:18 (CDT)
Dear Mr. O'Brien, My first experience with your work
was in a Modern Novel class at Northeastern University. We read "Going After
Cacciato". Although the line between reality and fantasy were blurred and initially
difficult to make sense of, further class discussion made clear the necessity of being
able to tell war stories. Of course, being one generation removed from the Vietnam era, I
find that historical fiction is a more effective way to get myself interested in the
events of the past. I am currently studying to be a teacher, and plan to use as much
literature as possible in any lessons I will teach. What Cacciato's story really helped me
to do, though, was reach out to my father. He is a Vietnam veteran, and from the very
little he has ever mentioned of it, his job was to bring functioning or repaired radio
equipment to troops in the bush. I offered your book to my dad, hoping he would read it
for his own benefit. Months passed, though, and it lay unopened, untouched on his desk. My
father has never told anyone of his experiences in Vietnam--not my mother, or any of my
brothers or sisters. Part of the difficulty that my family experienced as we grew up has
something to do with this. I am sure of it. I have just finished reading the portion of
"The Things They Carried" that appears in the Norton Anthology of Short Fiction.
Once again, I was moved by the human nature that so abundantly exudes from your writing. I
believe my father's wounds have yet to heal, and in light of the recent terms between
Vietnam and the US, my father is bitter. He has told me that to become friendly with
Vietnam is like a slap in the face. I feel sorry for my dad, and I would like to be able
to help him. It is obvious that you have overcome the grief of that war, at least to the
point that you can create stories about it. I don't know how you feel when you are
writing, and I wonder if you agree with my dad's opinion about feeling negated for the
time he served in the war. I suspect that your opinions may differ because while you have
moved on, my dad still hurts. Is there something I could do or say that might help my
father? Sincerely, Kristin
kristin madsen <kmadsen@lynx.neu.edu>
USA - Saturday, May 03, 1997 at 14:26:47 (CDT)
Dear Mr. O'Brien, I am a senior history major at
Gustavus Adolphus College. I am currently in the misdt of completeing "The Things
They Carried" for my Vietnam history class with Dr. Kevin Byrne. I wanted to write a
quick note to tell you how emotionally moved I was while reading this book. The chapter
entitled "On the Rainy River" was riveting. My question is, how much of this
book is true. Although you mention thrughout the book that a good war story does not need
to have an ending or a moral, the fact that these images are so real shock me. I could see
with my own eyes the tip of Canada off the small fishing boat. I wept when Kiowa was left
in the mud and shit, not knowing if he was dead or not. I was moved by "Speaking of
Courage" and "Notes" This book moved me, as well as giving me a picture of
what it was like. Although i will never be able to relate to these experiences, "The
Things They Carried" should be a must read for every college student!
Scott Tricker <stricker@gac.edu>
St. Peter, MN USA - Wednesday, April 30, 1997 at 12:11:20 (CDT)
Dear Mr.O'Brien - I think you are an amazing writer
and I hope that you continue to exploit your talents! I am a freshman at the University Of
Massachusetts Lowell and am currently writing a paper about both the work of yourself and
the stories written by Robert Olen Butler. I was wondering if you make visiting lectures
at schools in the East Coast. I would love to hear you speak at UMass Lowell! There are so
many fans here and it would be a great honor! Please keep up the great work and I just
want you to know that i am a HUGE fan of "The Things They Carried." My professor
here is also a great fan of your work. In class we read "How to Tell a True War
Story" and analyzed it! Thanks :) - Eve Lavendier
Eve Lavendier <LAVENDIEE@Woods.UML.edu>
Providence, RI USA - Tuesday, April 15, 1997 at 19:16:33 (CDT)
Hey Tim. How's your latest book coming? When do you
expect to have it published? I can't wait to read it. Take care.
Nancy <nbrteach@aol.com>
Lafayette, LA USA - Monday, April 14, 1997 at 19:31:13 (CDT)
I am reading The Things They Carried right now
because a student gave it to me. I read In the Lake of the Woods recently and gave it to
this same student. I recently had a conversation with a vet who told me the war didn't
bother him anymore, but then he told me about how he had been married five times. It
seemed to me that there might be a connection. I am also a friend of a friend of your,
Karen MacDowell, who was my student in the Goddard M.F.A. program.
Jane E. Wohl <wohl@wave.sheridan.wy.us>
Sheridan, WY USA - Tuesday, April 08, 1997 at 14:52:08 (CDT)
Hello Mr. O'Brien. I was introduced to "The
Things They Carried" last summer while taking a fiction writing course in my last
semester of undergrad. My professor handpicked your story for us to read and I have been
entranced with your writing since. I admire your intuitive way of describing things
without "describing" them - your subtle brushes of words instead of an abrubt
BANG of sentiments. I am reading In the Lake of the Woods at the moment. I feel myself
relating to Kathy(in her constant hope of what tomorrow may bring) and also with John(in
his desire to create a new life, just throw the rest at the back of the closet and deal
with it some other time...maybe never). How hard it is for you to recollect those times?
How do you remember without screaming? I would love to hear from you - Mindy
Mindy Debes <pegboy23>
Chicago, IL USA - Monday, April 07, 1997 at 21:10:46 (CDT)
This is impressive and unexpected. I originally came
here to do research for an esssay on "How to Tell a True War Story", but now I
plan to visit much more often!
Shaun Dehler <dehler@u.arizona.edu>
Tucson, AZ USA - Monday, March 31, 1997 at 15:47:41 (CST)
The Things They Carried is violent in its silence.
There is a silent power, the power of violence left unsaid. All is quiet in the moment of
horror. Tim O'Brien masters the emotional truth.
Kathy Corrice <corricka@maple.lemoyne.edu>
Syracuse, NY USA - Saturday, March 29, 1997 at 10:24:52 (CST)
I am in Lara's English 102 class at the University
of Arizona.Your novel "The Things They Carried" is so unique in it's
organization and it's truth in fiction approach. I loved it,and it opened my eyes to many
aspects of war. Thank you.
Teresa Shen <tshen@gas.uug.arizona.edu>
Tucson, AZ USA - Tuesday, March 25, 1997 at 21:43:35 (CST)
Reading In the Lake of the Woods depleted my
emotional resources completely. I am reading it for the second time right now.
Athalia Lujo <Athalia2@aol.com>
Weston, Fl USA - Sunday, March 23, 1997 at 15:46:48 (CST)
Here is a question for Tim if he actually ever reads
his homepage: I know that your work in progress is humorous and I was wondering if you
think a writer can hide his lack of talent behind humor? I am thinking of Woody Allen, who
is a comic genius, but there is no way he has the skills of say, Ralph Ellison, as a
novelist, and yet he was published in the New Yorker. So I was thinking that if one is
witty, one's wit may be enough to hide the fact that one doesn't have the skills of a
great writer. What do you think?
Daniel Conlon <has2dwc@atlas.vcu.edu>
Richmond , VA USA - Friday, March 21, 1997 at 13:11:01 (CST)
"Eloquently simple,and gripping" would be
my critic's blurb on the back cover of "The Things They Carried." Brilliant!
Matt Doherty <mdoherty@nwu.edu>
Evanston, Il USA - Thursday, March 20, 1997 at 17:43:24 (CST)
I read The Things They Carried for an American
Studies class on the 1960's in America. I have never been so moved by a piece of writing.
My mother was engaged to a pilot who was killed in Vietnam. Ten years later she married my
father and gave birth to me. If it hadn't been for Vietnam, I wouldn't be here. So I guess
that's my true war story. Thank you for helping me find it.
Jill Logan <jilllogan@mail.utexas.edu>
Austin, TX USA - Wednesday, March 19, 1997 at 20:41:10 (CST)
I am a Swedish student writing my Master thesis on
" The Vietnam War as a Disrupter of Reality in the Writings of Tim 'Brien". I
must admit that I am not certain wether I like his writings or not (except for The Things
They Carried, which I find brilliant); but I am fascinated by O'Briens treatment of the
concept of reality. Whoever claims that he is a magic realism writer is definitely afraid
of the literary conventions. Limitating works in order to understand them is NOT solving
anything. But what do I know? Well, I know feminism and war(fare) and enough of literature
to understand not to accept anything presented that I cannot agree upon. By the way:
anybody knowing where I can find T. J. Lomperis' "Reading the Wind: The Literature of
the Vietnam War: An Interpretive Critique" in the vicinity of Sweden where I do not
need to pay 80 dollars to procure it is welcome to tell me. It is not to be found in
Sweden, which annoys me greatly. Anybody wishing to communicate will find me on the above
email address..pls.mark the email ref. Ann-Sofie. Remember that order is just a denial of
chaos. Yrs truly...
Ann-Sofie Affleckt <m.kristensson@mbox200.swipnet.se>
Sweden - Wednesday, March 19, 1997 at 14:02:12 (CST)
Mr. O'brien, "Howdy!" from Texas I first
read The Things They Carried in the eighth grade for an english class, and it was one of
the most interesting books I've read. I am now a senior, and I'm writing my English term
paper (about you), and am reading In the Lake of the Woods. Although I'm not finished with
the book, so far it's wonderful. I would like to know, however, what advice you would give
a graduating senior considering a major in political science. Thanks, and please keep on
writing. There are thousands of boring english classes waiting for a little excitement.
Sincerely, Geoffrey T May
Geoffrey May
Dallas , Tx USA - Wednesday, March 19, 1997 at 08:59:45 (CST)
I've enjoyed reading your works and unlike many of
my peers, I don't care whether the sum is fiction or non-fiction. Keep up the good work.
Jessica Redlin <jayhawk>
Reston, VA USA - Friday, March 14, 1997 at 22:10:56 (CST)
Were you on LZ Stinson. 1-52 198th BDE Company E
Recon
Paul Bigham <bcr@bright.net>
Van Wert, Oh USA - Friday, March 14, 1997 at 06:59:21 (CST)
Tim: Thanks for an outstanding work on the what I
like to refer to as the "Viet Nam Experience." As a professor of English I have
always toyed with the idea of writing my own book about my own experiences decades ago.
Part of me wants to forget, part of me screams for recognition. I am going to try to put
tegether my own work but not so much on the war itself but what it did here at home. Mine
will be a story about a family torn apart by the war. It is a story of a family of two
sons, one died a hero in Viet Nam, one went to Canada to avoid the draft. Now, thirty
years later, the one son who survived finally comes home to face a father that hasn't
spoken to him in three decades and a country that still uses the war in Viet Nam as a
litmus test of patriotism.Any ideas that you might have will be greatly welcome.Best
WishesBryan
Bryan Gold <BryanG@Pacbell.net>
Woodland Hills, CA USA - Thursday, March 13, 1997 at 18:24:52 (CST)
I'm not really a big reader, but in my English class
I was exposed to a couple of the stories from Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried, and
those few weren't enough for me. So I went out and purchased a copy. I couldn't put it
down. I won't disrespect those who were there by saying it made me feel as if I were
there, but I will say that it made me better understand what exactly these brave men were
going through. Thanks for a great one, Mr. O'Brien. Keep it up.
Christopher Funke <csfunke@acsu.buffalo.edu>
Eden, NY USA - Thursday, March 13, 1997 at 17:42:29 (CST)
I have just started to read The Things They Carried
in myhigh school English class. I am very impressed with it. You are an excellent writer
and paint very vivid pictures ofwhat Vietnam must have been like. There needs to be
morepeople to tell us young people about the war. Rarely do wehear anything about what
happened there or what it was like.Thank you for doing that Mr. O'Brien.
Zachary Tirrell <ptirrell@sugar-river.com>
Lempster, NH USA - Saturday, March 08, 1997 at 15:43:20 (CST)
I have studied The Things They Carried twice in two
seperate lit. classes here at Prescott College. Its a masterpiece, my guide to creative
writing, story telling. When we would read ourfavorite bits in class, many classmates
would cry hard: Rainy River, the man I killed. I agree,I bawl each time I read last
chapter, about Linda. Thank you brother!
Chris Erichsen <none>
Prescott, AZ USA - Thursday, March 06, 1997 at 18:09:11 (CST)
Turtle. Tampa.
Sean Gillihan <gillihan@cdsnet.net>
Klamath Falls, OR USA - Thursday, February 27, 1997 at 11:58:47 (CST)
I had to read "The Things They Carried"
for English class, and I enjoyed very much. I am thinking of doing my research paper on
it, also. Adeus
Eric Plant <s22405ep@umassd.edu>
New Bedford, MA USA - Wednesday, February 26, 1997 at 09:53:44 (CST)
I enjoyed reading your book, In the Lake of the
Woods. I am looking forward to reading more of your novels.
Jeff Ruth <jdr3353@unix.tamu.edu>
College Station, TX USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:36:44 (CST)
Mr. O'Brien, we are reading In the Lake of the Woods
in our English class at Texas A&M University. I have to know what really happened to
Kathy, if you can tell me.
erich mcelroy <jfm9560@unix.tamu.edu>
College Station, Tx USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:36:10 (CST)
What really happened to his wife?What was the
significance of the man with the hoe?Does Tim O'Brien have flackbacks of Vietnam?
Anna Comingore <fac1435@juno.com>
Bryan, tx USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:33:42 (CST)
Good book! My classmates are dwelling on the trivial
details and focusing on the mystery rather than considering the introspection that the
book encourages. However I will refuse to be mislead and enjoy your book for what it is,
more social commetary and less of a mystery.
Nathan Flack <njf7627@Tam2k.Tamu.edu>
college station, tx USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:33:30 (CST)
I just finished reading In the Lake of the Woods for
a liturature class.Just wanted to drop a line from Aggieland to tell you that I
thoughtyour novel was great!
Crystal Creel <cec0670@unix.tamu.edu>
College Station, TX USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:28:51 (CST)
What-ever!
Cher Horowitz <duchess@clueless.com>
Beverly Hills, CA USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:23:40 (CST)
I thought In the Lake of the Woods was a great
story. I have done a research paper on the My Lai incident and I was quite impressed with
the facts you presented. I'm looking foward to reading more of your books.
Shawn Eyre <smtex@myriad.net>
Bryan, TX USA - Tuesday, February 25, 1997 at 08:21:32 (CST)
Tim O'Brien is by far my favorite writer and I
always keep an eye out for any of his short stories in the New Yorker. Hope he never
stops.
Chad Wierschke <cwwierschke@osprey.smcm.edu>
St. Mary's City, MMD USA - Friday, February 21, 1997 at 15:28:24 (CST)
In the Lake of the Woods is my favorite book of all
times, and propelled me to read as many other Tim O'Brien books as I could. I was not much
of a reader before , but now I read as much as I can.
Will Ryan
USA - Thursday, February 13, 1997 at 16:23:37 (CST)
I like your homepage. Have not read your books yet
but will when I find at the local bookstore or library. My husband was with a Americal
Unit Contact him tdbri@gulftel.com . He likes to share stories with the guys. I was a vet
that served 1973 to 1977 and 1983 to 1985 so I have never been in war but help take of our
people at Fort Sam and Fort Hood Texas. Donna
Donna Brizendine <tdbriz@gulftel.com>
Silverhill, Al USA - Monday, February 10, 1997 at 23:09:18 (CST)
Great site -- Im doing a term paper on Tim O'Brien
and i wish that you would have a larger biography section.
Nick <atombom@aol.com >
USA - Monday, February 10, 1997 at 16:49:00 (CST)
hi tim, i enjoy reading your books. your fellow
classmatebecky simons vorsten
becky simons vorsten <bschmitz@pionet.net>
USA - Thursday, February 06, 1997 at 21:18:18 (CST)
Return to the Tim O'Brien's Home Page
|
|
|