Tim O'Brien's Guestbook-1998

Tim O'Brien's 1999 Guest Book

Return to the current guest book.

Hope to see you in Austin soon. Joe Galloway and Dr. Ron Glasser want to give you a call. Wallace 1/35th 25th Div.
Wallace Craig <whc@texasonline.net>
Midland, Tx USA - Thursday, December 30, 1999 at 18:58:03 (CST)

I thought the book was pretty good,My favorite part of the book was when the dog got blown up on the claymore mine.I also liked the part where Kiowa drowned. Overall the book was pretty good.
Andrew Trimble
Coarsegold, Ca USA - Wednesday, December 29, 1999 at 23:14:30 (CST)

JUST STARTED TOMCAT IN LOVE, IF IT CONTINUES AS IT HAS STARTED, THIS WILL BE SOME GREAT READ. THANKS FOR YOUR OTHER BOOKS ON VIETNAM, I SERVED DURING 1966 & 1970, BUT NEVER WENT "IN COUNTRY" I READ YOU TO EXPERIANCE WHAT I WILL NEVER KNOW. I'VE ALWAYS FELT I COULD NOT CALL MYSELF A VET BECAUSE I NEVER SERVED OVER THERE; AIR FORCE AND STAYED STATE SIDE. I PLAN TO READ THE THINGS THEY CARRIED IN HOPES IT ALSO WILL HELP ME SEE WHAT YOU EXPERIANCED AND ME UNDERSTAND. THANKS AGAIN,
GERALD ROPER <JERRY-ROPER@USCRAWCO.COM>
JACKSONVILLE, FL USA - Wednesday, December 29, 1999 at 21:58:19 (CST)

It's been a great and enlightening time reading your books. Thanks! Happy Christmas and a Happy New Year!
Ivan Velev <Ivan_Velev@excite.com>
Sofia, Bulgaria - Monday, December 27, 1999 at 02:49:02 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien, I really enjoyed your book, "The Things They Carried". I thought it was exteremly well written and really conveyed the true feeling of the Vietnam war. Thank you on behalf of everyone my age (16) for writing a book that so clearly dipicts the war for those of us that weren't around to experience it.
Ryan Collings
Oakhurst, CA USA - Tuesday, December 14, 1999 at 22:18:20 (CST)

I thought that the book "The Things They Carried" was very interesting. It was wounderful the way that you explained evaery thing in such great and serious detail. You wern't afraid to say what it was really like . I think that makes the book even more interesting. I hope to read another one of your stories some time.
Jillian Cochran
oakhurst, Ca USA - Tuesday, December 14, 1999 at 21:16:09 (CST)

Mr. Tim O'Brien , I have recently read your book "The Things They Carried" , I must say i was rather impressed with your ability to discribe the veitnam war so vividly . I must say though I personally did not care for the chapter when the baby water buffalo got shot. I thought that was kind of cruel but i guess thats just the way things have to be . I really injoyed reading your book . I hope other kids will like it too .
Georgia Dean <N/a>
Coarsegold , ca USA - Monday, December 13, 1999 at 16:19:30 (CST)

This book has opened up a new world of interest for life. I served for a short time in the army. I am only 23 years old. There were many a night during basic when I imagined having to go to war. This book brought all those imaginations to life. I felt a true connections to the soilders of Alpha co. I can't wait to read all of your books. Thankyou for true enlightment.
Julio M. Salgado <jjsalgado_2000@yahoo.com>
naugatuck, ct USA - Monday, December 13, 1999 at 12:35:35 (CST)

The Things they Carried opened my eyes to the real definition of "truth." One of the best books I've ever read.
Jeff Van Hooser <jvanhoos@umich.edu>
Ann Arbor, MI USA - Sunday, December 12, 1999 at 23:48:28 (CST)

Hey Tim I really liked your book "The things they carried". I think it's one of the best books i've ever read even though i haven't read that many books.I like the realness of the book it's makes you feel like I'm right there next to you see all this stuff happen. I also like this book because you educate people about what the war was like.
Ben Rowlett
Oakhurst, Ca USA - Thursday, December 09, 1999 at 23:02:51 (CST)

my class and I just finished reading "The Things They Carried". At first I wasn't really into the book because of the subject and the gore. The details made me sick to my stomach. I wanted to stop reading the book. Then after I learned a little about the veitnam war and after i got use to all of the characters in the book, then I loved the book. I realized that the sick feeling that i got in my stomach is a sign of a wonderful writer. The details were amazing. especialy the part about the poor water buffalo. I think this book is the first school book that I have enjoyed.
taryn faust <none>
coarsegold, ca USA - Thursday, December 09, 1999 at 18:41:33 (CST)

This has to be the best book that I have ever read. I did not realize that the weight of mental possesions was the hardest thing for you to carry. Thanks for making me be thankful for those that I have.
William Musso <wcm1628@hotmail.com>
Gonzales, LA USA - Thursday, December 09, 1999 at 16:38:52 (CST)

Dear Mr. O'Brien, I really liked your book "The Things They Carried". The description you used I thought was fantastic and thorough. I like how the reader almost feels as though they were part of the story when read. I bet if the normal guy or girl went through what happened in your book they would probably be pretty messed up mentally and most likely physically also. P.S. The WaterBuffalo part was pretty effective.
Nathan Aubin <deathkn@hotmail.com>
Oakhurst, CA USA - Tuesday, December 07, 1999 at 21:47:01 (CST)

I think the book was very interesting. The book wasn't just one long story, it had many storys. Each chapter was diffrent. The descriptive writting made the book better than others.
gemini nokes
ahwahnee, ca USA - Tuesday, December 07, 1999 at 16:16:51 (CST)

MY NAME IS ROOSEVELT COOKS AND I JUST READ YOUR BOOK IN MY 11TH GRADE ENGLISH CLASS AND UNLIKE SOME OF THE OTHER PEOPLE IN YOUR GUEST BOOK I DIDN'T SEE THE HIDDEN MESSAGES LIKE DROP OUT OF SCHOOL I JUST THOUGHT IT WAS A GOOD BOOK
Roosevelt Cooks <r.cooks9900@edmail.com>
Coarsegold, CA USA - Tuesday, December 07, 1999 at 15:52:55 (CST)

Tim, I'm really enjoying your book, THE THINGS THEY CARRIED, and think that you're an awesome and very creative writer. We could all use some of that in our A. Literature classes! Anyways, great book. I especially like all the great mental pictures you give us, and how nothing is sugar-coated, and everything is "true." I'm sure I'll read this book more than once, and maybe a few others....
Andy Brooks <brooks_bunch@yahoo.com>
small hic town, CA USA - Monday, December 06, 1999 at 19:32:00 (CST)

Dear Mr. O'Brien, I have just read some of the other letters posted by some of the students that have read your book and found them to be very naive. To me, your books aren't about the Viet Nam war, rather they are about human nature. I think Going After Cacciato best exeplifies my point. Some people may suggest that you 'put the war behind you', which is the most absurd thing that anyone could possibly say after reading your works. The war is not something that happened to you a long time ago. It's a part of you that lives on deep inside you human structure.
Anyways, back to the reason I was writing this note to you. I am 19 years old and am currently attending Fordham college. I had read The Things They Carried when I was in high school and was engrossed. For one of my english papers this year, I decided to analyze The Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong. I went to re-read it and found myself five hours later having read the whole book yet again. I found one part of the book to be especially meaningful to me. In On the Rainy River, when you are faced with the decision to flee to Canada or stay and go to war. The sentences that resinated again and again in my mind were: "I was a coward. I went to war."
Now, why these particular lines would mean so much to a 19 year old college student is this: Upon coming to college I had the realization that this was not the path my life wanted to take. I knew that deep down inseide, a little voice was telling me that this was not in my soul. Soon that little voice turned into a full born yell that, try as I might, I could not ignore. See, Fordham was my Viet Nam and my Canada was my dream, my passion, of music. I read your story and immediatly I was in that rowboat: at a point in my life where I could either follow my dreams and soul or be a coward and stay at Fordham. I was scared to follow my heart because of what everybody else back home would think. I would be labled a failure and be followed by pitiful voices whispering 'there goes Brian. He had such great oppotunities but he pissed them all away.'
So there I was at this impass. I picked up your book, read it again, and decided that I wasn't going to be a coward. That I was going to live my own life and not let the unheard opinions of others stand in my way of true happiness. I just wanted to thank you, Mr. O'Brien, for allowing me to see what was inside me and how to not be a coward. I officially dropped out of Fordham college today and am going back home to pursue my dream and happiness. Whether I make it or not is irrelevant because at least I would have tried and forty years down the road, I won't have a voice inside me saying 'what if.'
See. Your stories aren't about war at all. Once again, much thanks.

Brian O'Connor <cadaverdog@hotmail.com>
USA - Monday, December 06, 1999 at 17:15:23 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien.... My name is Aaron and my Literature Class is currently working on a website for your novel Going After Cacciato. We could really use your help! If we could get an email interview with you or something that would be greatly appreciated! PLEASE email me and let me know! THANKS for your time! Aaron
Aaron Stickland <awstick@indiana.edu>
Bloomington, IN USA - Monday, December 06, 1999 at 13:02:11 (CST)

I liked your book "The Theings They Carried". I was a real expierence
Silvestre Reeve <Scgbp@yahoo.com>
Oakhurst, Ca USA - Thursday, December 02, 1999 at 23:09:40 (CST)

Just finished your book. "The Things They Carried" I must say I have never read a book like this one. Not only does it take you through the jungles of Vietnam, but it makes you think about things. Things that you would never think about on a daily basis. It puts an image in your mind that you do not want to see. I won't go into detail, but lets just say dead people with missing limbs is not a pretty sight.
Greg G.
Oakhurst, CA USA - Thursday, December 02, 1999 at 22:42:14 (CST)

I just finished reading your book "the things they carried", The book gave a great discription of war. You did a great job discribing the physical as well as the emotional things that the soldiers carried with them. I didn't really think the book was that great in the beginning but ater a few chapters I really liked reading it.
Josie Morris
Ahwahnee, Ca USA - Thursday, December 02, 1999 at 22:13:35 (CST)

I am reading your book,The Things They Carried, and I think it is interesting. This is the first book that actually keeps me reading. I am not a big reader and I find books very boring. The thing I like about your book is the fact that it gives good descriptions on how the war really was. Even though some of your stories were not true, I still like your book.
Melissa Arce
Oakhurst, Ca USA - Thursday, December 02, 1999 at 17:45:40 (CST)

I just got finished with the book "The Things they Carried" I thought the book had a great amount of detail that gave me, which made the so much more interesting. I myself have a family member who faught in the Vietnam war. He served in the U.S Navy in the cold war too. I have a great respect for my father because he was one of the many that served our country. It was a great book for me to read it because I was able to see the army/marines side of the war and what they expierenced. In some of the chapters it was hard to handle what was going on,some almost even made me cry. Because of the gruesome details of men dying and the way the Americans treated the VC. I'm also learning about the Vietnam war in U.S History and so far I think its interesting. I'm not really the kind of person that is all for the war and all. If i had to drafted, I would inlist in the Navy like my dad , I don't think that I could handle hand to hand combat. But I do have the guts to,if I couldn't choose. I recemmend this book to people that are really into the war and enjoy reading aboutwar stories. True or False, usually both are interesting. This is one of those books that you will always remember about reading. After reading this book I think I'm going to read another one of you're books.
Michelle Smith
North Fork, Ca USA - Thursday, December 02, 1999 at 17:29:35 (CST)

I'M READING YOUR BOOK THINGS THEY CARRIED IN MY ENGLISH. I FIND THIS BOOK QUIET INTERSTING BECAUSE OF THE WAY YOU DESCIBE THINGS THAT HAPPEN OR WHAT YOU HAVE DREAM'T OR WHAT YOU HAVE MADE UP. ALLTHESE THINGS MAKES ME PICTURE IT IN MY MIND AND I END UP WITH A FEELING LIKE I WAS THERE OR I CAN FEEL WHAT THEY FEEL OR FELT. YOU DID A WOUNDERFUL JOB ON THE DESCRIPTIVENESS OF THE BOOK.
Corina Malcolm
coarsegold, CA USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 23:16:53 (CST)

I JUST FINISHED READING A GOOD BOOK CALLED "THE THINGS THEY CARRIED." I LEARNED A LOT ABOUT WHAT THE VIETNAM SOLDIERS HAD TO FACE AND LIVE WITH ON A DAILY BASIS. I WOULD REALLY RECOMEND THIS BOOK TO EVERYONE.
NICK CAREY <NCAREY_E12@HOTMAIL.COM>
COARSEGOLD, CA USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 22:55:35 (CST)

I have just finished reading your book "The Things They Carried" in my 11 grade English class. I thought it was a very interesting book, with many strange accounts of war time situations. I fealt the great descriptions the book portrayed, gave the reader an actual feeling of what it might be like to witness this war. However, I found the book to be quite confussing at times and hard to follow.
Phillip Parks
Ahwahnee, Ca USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 20:23:30 (CST)

I thought the book was very well designed,(sorry, I would be talking about "The Things They Carried") I liked the way it was put together; yet, very confusing. Instead of using others(yours) view of the vietnam war I had to think for myself,and actually make my own impressions of the vietnam war. I would have to say that now that your a famous writer, you should put the whole vietnam war behind you, write other things, and value the things you still have, For example, bring your wife home some flowers and find the blessings you have recieved from your hevenly father. Before I read your book, I had know idea how bad this war really was. I am very thankful for teachers that teach me about things of great importance such as the vietnam war and watergate scandle. Then later on in my life I won't be imbarassed because I know what these things are and why America did what it did. Signed with thanks, David Fletcher
David Fletcher <fletchson@aol.com>
Ahwahnee, CA `USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 17:35:09 (CST)

I JUST FINISHED "THE THINGS THEY CARRIED",I READ IT FOR MY 11TH GRADE ENGLISH CLASS IT WAS GREAT. ALL OF THE STORIES GAVE SUCH A TRUTHFULL LOOK INTO THE VIETNAM WAR. EVEN IF IT WAS THE TRUTH OR FICTION
nathan tucker
coarsegold, ca USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 16:24:45 (CST)

I HAVE READ YOUR BOOK IN MY ENGLISH CLASS AND HAVE TOTALLY ENJOYED IT. AT FRIST I WASN'T TO SURE IF I REALLY LIKED IT BUT NOW I'M CERTAIN THAT I DO AND I WOULD LIKE TO READ SOME MORE OF YOUR WRITTINGS.
kristi moberly <kris_16_@hotmail.com>
ahwahnee, CA USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 15:12:54 (CST)

"The Things They Carried" was one of the most well written book I have ever read, seriosly. It seemed as if you were my dad or grandpa just sitting around telling me war stories. The way you wrote it actually made me feel the intense feelings that I was meant to feel by reading it. Maybe not the real feelings of the war but definitly some major ones. It changed the way I look at things a little and that little bit must count for something.
shellie key
oakhurst, ca USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 15:09:52 (CST)

I have read your book The Things They Carried in my junior english class. I liked the book. I learned a lot about Vietnam. You really did a great job on each story that was written. I think that the way you wrote to leave your readers wondering which of it was true was pretty unique. P.S. RUSSELL CARNEY RULES!!!!! and thinks that your book was rockin'.
Kim Vanderputten <k_dawg51@hotmail.com>
coarsegold, CA USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 12:51:49 (CST)

Found it while looking for a research project for Am. Lit.
Marco Hensse <dparrott@csra.net>
Evans, Georgia USA - Wednesday, December 01, 1999 at 12:05:10 (CST)

I have read the things they carried a couple of times now and I've decided to make a report on it this time. The descriptions in this story have really caught my attention and the way they were laid had me much attached to keep me interested. I haven't read many of your stories because I'm not much of a reader but I'll try to follow up for many like thisone and of course by the same author. This particular story I believe should live to open visions of many who people who have some type of consideration for veterans and appreciate the masterpiece work of a talented author.
Alex Verastegui <phessional@hotmail.com>
central islip, ny USA - Tuesday, November 30, 1999 at 11:49:23 (CST)

I'm doing an author report on you and I think that your stories are very interesting.
Michael Hogan <Michael_321@hotmail.com>
Plainfield, IL USA - Tuesday, November 23, 1999 at 13:12:16 (CST)

I read your book, "The Things They Carried" for a history of American War and Society class recently. I wanted to thank you for a perspective that I never had before about Vietnam. The book made me feel as if I were a part of the war, which evoked very strong feelings. My step-father was a soldier in Vietnam and I think that this book has helped me to understand some of what he went through while he was there. Thank you.
Jaclyn <cntryzta@aol.com>
Chino, Ca USA - Tuesday, November 23, 1999 at 02:09:54 (CST)

Tim, I was a little disapointed to see that so many people are as fond of you as I, I liked believing that you were my little secret. I have read all you have attatched to paper, In the Lake of The Woods being my personal favorite. Tom Cat in Love comes in at a close second. "Fiji, my lost princess, is but a state of mind. Embolden yourself. Brave the belief." Now that is a sentance. Take care. tami
Tami Baker-Olson <tjolson@gateway.com>
Mahtomedi , MN USA - Monday, November 22, 1999 at 14:02:45 (CST)

I am a college freshman at Morehead State University. I recently finished "The Things They Carried". You have given me new respect for anyone who has ever served in combat. I want to thank you for bringing me as close as I've ever been, to a world I hope I'll never know.
Rudy Franklin
Morehead, Ky USA - Friday, November 19, 1999 at 21:22:35 (CST)

Dear Mr. Obrian My senior class and I have just finished reading The Things They Carried and I must say that it is fabulous! In all my life I have never read a novel that was better written than this was. I fell in love with the style and the characters and was unable to put this novel down. While my class was asigned to read it in two weeks, I finished it in one night. I love the way you are able to make the reader BELIEVE which is truly what makes great writing. Luckily, my teacher has much knowledge about this novel and was able to interpret things for us so that we can fully appreciate this masterpiece. At the end I cant help but wonder: Was kiowa ficticious or a real person and did he really suffer that tragic death..?; Did you really re-visit Vietnam years later with you're daughter?. This is simply because in this great novel you never know if something really did happen or if it was just made up and written in such a way that the reader is forced to BELIEVE. You are truly a great writer Mr. O'brian. The thing that puts you ahead of all other writers is you're ability to make the reader BELIEVE, FEEL and ABSORB you're writing whether it be fiction or non. Keep up the good work sir! -John
John Ambrose <jambrose14@hotmail.com>
Pleasantville, NY USA - Thursday, November 18, 1999 at 21:45:26 (CST)

I really like your style of writting. I've read Going After Cacciato, The Things They Carried and In the Lake of the Woods. I thought they were all great.
Michael Hogan <Michael_321@hotmail.com>
Plainfield, IL USA - Thursday, November 18, 1999 at 13:26:59 (CST)

Hi I'd like to know where I could find the short story "The Things They Carried". I need it for my English class. If somebody could please send it to me or tell me how to get it I would really appreciate it. Just email me
Dan <platinum_99@hotmail.com>
Canada - Sunday, November 14, 1999 at 19:12:14 (CST)

Just turned on the tube this morning and listened to what you and Joe rodriguiz had to say on c-span. Igave me some insight to how we have lived our lives after we came home. I was also with the americal from 1968-1969. Keep spreading the word. Its not where we have been but where we are going.
michael gordon <mgordon@tisd.net>
port lavaca, tx USA - Friday, November 12, 1999 at 06:36:25 (CST)

MY DAUGHTER READ YOUR BOOK,THE THINGS THEY CARRIED,FOR HER SENIOR CLASS. SHE WAS NEVER SO DEEPLY TOUCHED BY A BOOK AS WAS SHE WITH YOURS.FOR THIS I THANK YOU
SHARYL FORD <SHARYLF@GOTSI.COM>
ROHNERT PARK, CA USA - Wednesday, November 10, 1999 at 08:37:06 (CST)

I am doing a presentation onyou and your works for my Modern Fiction class at the college. I have read a couple of your works and think they are fabulous.
Krystal <krys@ipa.net>
Joplin, MO USA - Sunday, November 07, 1999 at 20:56:30 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien We read part of your book "The Things They Carried", as published in Edgar Roberts English Text book. I can't begin to tell you how much I enjoyed it and am goint to read the rest of the story as Mr. Harvey says as soon as possible. I'm a Vet myself please keep writing Thanks Mitch Mattson
Mitch Mattson <mmmjkmncms@aol.com>
Lubbock, tx USA - Sunday, November 07, 1999 at 06:56:10 (CST)

Thank you for the reading and the chance to meet you a second time. Where are you? Best, Evetta
evetta andersson <eaa11@cornell.edu>
Ithaca, NY USA - Friday, November 05, 1999 at 12:21:39 (CST)

My father was in vietnam, I am 18 years old. He never told me of his experiences. However i was assigned to read the book the things they carried. It was a very enjoyable and informitive book. Not to mention that it was a nicley written piece of work. The book made me think about life in general. *applause* Mr. O'Brian you have given the gift of a story. My fathers story. As in your book with that story i saved my fathers life. Even though he has passed, He is alive. Sincerly, Alicia Mayersky
Alicia Mayersly <AMayersky73641@aol.com>
Sauk Village , IL USA - Thursday, November 04, 1999 at 21:49:57 (CST)

I saw Tim O'Brien last night at UC Riverside where he read passages from The Things They Carried. Tim O'Brien the character and Tim O'Brien in reality is intriguing and mystifying. You can't ascertain who is the real Tim O'Brien. He is sincere and honest; however, he keeps you guessing. The man is truly a genius.Story truths may be more real than real truths; O'Brien has me pleasantly perplexed.
Sunbie Harrell <www.ms dazien@aol.com>
Fullerton, CA USA - Wednesday, November 03, 1999 at 17:19:17 (CST)

My English 2 class recently read "Where have you gone charming Billy?" We are also including biographical data about you in a short story notebook. However, I am having trouble locating current information. Could you help me out? I know my English teacher would be really impressed if I got my information straight from the author himself. Of course, she would be even more impressed if you could visit our class at Hobbs High School in Hobbs, NM. I hope you can e-mail a reply before Thursday, Nov. 4 because my notebook is due on Friday. Thanks!
Logan McIlroy <lmcilroy@webtv.net>
Hobbs, NM USA - Tuesday, November 02, 1999 at 21:25:20 (CST)

Die �berarbeitete Fassung deines Buches "Was sie trugen" finde ich wirklich spitze. Danke
Damian Litzka <litzka-silver@t-online.de>
Bremen, Germany - Tuesday, November 02, 1999 at 07:52:23 (CST)

I am just on the last chapter of "The things They Carried." It has helped me to some degree. My war was in Africa, The Rwanda genocide. I am presently writing a book on it. All wars have similarities. Thanks Tim. I think you are still haunted. I can't shake it after 5 yrs. It lives on. We are the same age and I sense like me, the boogie man still comes at night. Keep writing. I know you get it allot, but I would love to talk to you. Maybe someday you will read my book if it gets published.
Capt. Dave Melanson, MSM, CD <padre@kosnet.com>
Kingston, ON Canada - Wednesday, October 27, 1999 at 11:22:46 (CDT)

im finishing a thesis on the media and the vietnam era for school. can anyone please tell me the name of or link me to a web sight with photographs of the perhaps one of the most famous photos of that time. i refer to the photo of the vietnamese man being executed with a pistol shot to the head in the middle of the street with his hands tied behind his back. (i think). the photo was in black and white and was shown repeatedly and is still shown but i am unable to locate it on the internet. please write me and razzell2@aol.com or razzell2@mscomm.com with any information, please. thank you.
russell munson <razzell2@mscomm.com>
phelan, ca USA - Sunday, October 24, 1999 at 17:18:37 (CDT)

I recently saw Tim O'Brien read from "The Things They Carried" in Ithaca, NY and later spent the evening hanging with him and some friends. All in all, it was an excellant time. I only wish I had not missed the opportunity that I gave up....
Chloe Mills <cmills1@twcny.rr.com>
Ithaca, NY USA - Saturday, October 23, 1999 at 14:33:17 (CDT)

I LOVED both "In the Lake of the Woods" and "Tomcat in Love"; I think you are the most poetic author I have ever read. I often jot down some of the lines from your books because the writing touches me. I know nothing about writing a screenplay, but the language and characters in "Tomcat in Love" were so compelling. I'm sure that the book has been optioned, but if it hasn't and you are willing to think about this, I'd be very happy to hear from you. I really don't know how to go about it any other way! Despite all that, you are my favorite author and are so unique in your writing style. At first I thought you were a poet.
Katharine Draper <kathydaffy@aol.com>
Northampton, MA USA - Saturday, October 23, 1999 at 14:10:28 (CDT)

We do a cable television show featuring authors who come to Kettering Ohio to sign books. My students produce the show and students from Kettering Fairmont High School who are interested in writing come to be the audience. If you ever do a book signing tour to Books and Co in Kettering Ohio please contact Kettering Fairmont 937 296-7711 Ask for Karl Bremer.
Karl Bremer <radiotv@erinet,com>
Franklin, OH USA - Friday, October 22, 1999 at 09:04:48 (CDT)

Tim, I also served in the Americal, Jan 69 to Jan 70 with Co A 1/6th INF, 198th LIB (Gunfighters). Went to the VVA National Convention in Anaheim CA this summer and met up with two members of the 1/6th. Brought back memories, some that I buried for 30 yrs. Have not read any of your writing but intend to do so. Peace. Craig
Craig R. Singer <csinger@palihost.state.pa.us>
Kersey, PA USA - Monday, October 18, 1999 at 15:25:13 (CDT)

great site! love Tims' books too!
Matt
Bronx, ny us of a - Saturday, October 16, 1999 at 16:57:09 (CDT)

Tim, I started to sign in on this a year ago when we bought a new US Lit text that had a TOB selection. I decided at the time that too much time in the offing, but now I'm home recovering from surgery. Guess I'll give this another go.
Steve Fields '66 <spjsjnf004@aol.com>
Dubuque, IA USA - Tuesday, October 12, 1999 at 16:05:23 (CDT)

I am a junior at Las Plumas High School and I am reading "The things they carried" for US History. We are doing a report on the historical novel of our choice and the author of the novel. I just have to say that it is an excellent book!
Clint Allison <butthead39@hotmail.com>
Oroville, CA USA - Sunday, October 10, 1999 at 21:07:59 (CDT)

Tim o'brian, i am studying "in the lake of the woods" at school, and i think it kicks ass, there are some sooky vietnamese people in my class who think your book sucked and that you were simply racist, but the way you potrayed John Wade was all to common of what troubles and pressure the "gooks" put on our guys, give em hell
adam <atuck@alphalink.com.au>
Greenvale, Vic Australia - Wednesday, October 06, 1999 at 06:04:12 (CDT)

To:Tim O'Brien, I have read your book, and I personally think you are racist, and that you do not know anything about Vietnamese people, so I personally think that you shouldn't make any duragatory comments about Vietnamese people. You might think that you know a lot about Vietnamese people because you were involved in the Vietnam War and because you stayed in Vietnam for a long period of time but that has nothing to do with racial slurs. "Gook" isn't a proper word for us Vietnamese people we are Vietnamese. Do you think that it is okay for me to call you a peice of shit trailer trashed ass cracker? I didn't think so. Concerns from Ms. Tina Nguyen
Tina Nguyen <www.Cycogrlaos@aol.com>
San Diego, CCA USA - Tuesday, October 05, 1999 at 21:50:14 (CDT)

If anyone knows how I can get in touch with Tim O'Brien, I would be eternally grateful. I am a film school student interested in turning "Church" from The Things the Carried into a short film for school. Going through the publisher and his agent hasn't been productive. Again, if anyone knows anything, PLEASE LET ME KNOW. Eternally grateful.
Bretton Zinger <bzinger@aol.com>
London, UK - Monday, October 04, 1999 at 17:14:24 (CDT)

I served with Americal A 1/6, 198th Inf. Bde in 1969.
J. R. O'Bryan <JOB1310708@AOL.Com>
Macon, GA USA - Friday, October 01, 1999 at 20:42:27 (CDT)

Our class is currently in the computer lab trying to find the e-mail address of Tim O'Brien to ask him about the validity of The Things They Carried. Is it truly fiction? I think that it is because it is just his mastery of the English language that he so easily is able to manipulate.
Andrea Vigil <avigil@fvs.edu>
Colorado Springs, CO USA - Thursday, September 30, 1999 at 12:37:43 (CDT)

I'm in the midst of Tomcat in Love. If I ever ever write this well...I honestly know the main character of this book. (Both literally and figuratively). Writing professors always say that characters take on a life of their own and meander in and out of things unexpectedly. Finding the main character, a grown man, sobbing in the back yard of his old home is so not-surprising. However, I have a hard time believing that O'Brien sent the character there...I think he went on his own accord. I saw O'Brien do a reading at Macalister College in 1994 (In the Lake of the Woods) and have been a fan since. He says things that everyone wants to say but do not know how. And brilliant with dialogue. I could go on...
Christa Lawler <lilgrl190@hotmail.com>
Rochester, MN USA - Wednesday, September 29, 1999 at 01:50:04 (CDT)

I just read The Things They Carried.I don't think words can express how I felt after this book. It is simply astonishing when a book can make you feel so many different things! I loved it and I plan on continuing with Tim O'brien. I normally read Science-Fiction books by Terry Brooks, but with this book, I just felt like I had to keep going.......
Racheal Wall <Paisly_99@yahoo.com>
LaSalle, Illinois USA - Tuesday, September 28, 1999 at 17:16:39 (CDT)

We are studying "In the Lake of the Woods" and found this site immensely helpful!!! Tim O'Brien's "In the Lake of the Woods" is truly an inspirational novel; very mysterious and intriguing; without doubt the best book I have read this year.
Jolia <jopeach4174@hotmail.com>
Australia - Monday, September 06, 1999 at 21:20:04 (CDT)

I am in college studying English. We recently read the short story the Things They Carried. It was excellent.
Celeste Wille <cwille@earthlink.net>
Chesapeake, VA USA - Thursday, September 02, 1999 at 14:06:13 (CDT)

United States Military Academy Cadet Right now, we are going over the essay, "How To Tell A True Story." Just wanted to let you know, I thought it was a great essay.
Landgrave Smith <x35725@usma.edu>
West Point, NY USA - Tuesday, August 31, 1999 at 21:39:25 (CDT)

I was just reading through all of the other sign-ins and I didn't see anything for "Tomcat in Love". This is the best book that I have read in a long time. All of my friends have either read it or are in the process. You all should try it.
Sandy <whitetshirts@hotmail.com>
USA - Tuesday, August 31, 1999 at 09:13:06 (CDT)

Just surfin' and found this site. I have read about ten books about tours by enlisted men in Nam. I especially enjoy books written by LLRP's and recon. I will try to obtain a copy of Tim O'Brien's book. I will bookmark this site and return to it. So far it is GREAT! May the force be with you. Regards, Art.
Art Robichaud Jr <art.robichaud@pei.sympatico.ca>
Souris, P.E.I. Canada - Sunday, August 29, 1999 at 16:09:49 (CDT)

Mr. O'Briens precise prose, moral vision, and love inspire me. "I was a coward: I went to the war" is a monument to courage, as is his dedication to writing to us as he wrestles with truth.
Larry Colan <LColan@aol.com>
Mahopac, NY USA - Friday, August 27, 1999 at 00:22:47 (CDT)

Anybody ever hear from Tim or is this just a groupie hang-out? I was going to order Northern Lights from the UK, but being a grunt myself, I could not stand the word "Bloody" replacing the F--- word!!! or "Boot" replacing the word "Trunk." That's not the way it was.
Dave Hammond <hammond@ipinc.net>
Beaverton, OR USA - Tuesday, August 24, 1999 at 23:30:06 (CDT)

I have been in the USA for an exchange program and read your book in english class. I love it!!! It is written very well and talks about the true things that really happened during the Vietnam War. I learned alot through this book. Now I am trying to bye it, but I don�t know how to get to it from Germany. Maybe somebody could help me. Thanks.
Silke <Schmitz-Meisenbach@t-online.de>
Meisenbach, Germany - Sunday, August 22, 1999 at 03:53:54 (CDT)

I have been in the USA for an exchange program and read your book in english class. I love it!!! It is written very well and talks about the true things that really happened during the Vietnam War. I learned alot through this book. No I am trying to bye it, but I don�t know how to get to it from Germany. Maybe somebody could help me. Thanks.
Silke <Schmitz-Meisenbach@t-online.de>
Meisenbach, Germany - Sunday, August 22, 1999 at 03:53:12 (CDT)

read your book the things they carried...absolutely amazing novel! just wanted to tell you i thought you did a wonderful job. i've spoken to alot of people who have also read it and some of your other work and i've only heard great things. we were assigned to read it in my english class in st.paul, where many people happen to know you! just wanted to tell you how much i enjoyed the book. good luck in future novels!
marina yould <cco1@ prodigy.net>
ft.lauderdale, fl USA - Friday, August 20, 1999 at 00:58:17 (CDT)

Literary travesty update! I'm still reading "Northern Lights," (O'Brien, published in the UK, Flamingo Books), and on page 253 "airplane" is spelled "aeroplane." Also, on page 135, Bishop Markham and Paul are driving with two Christmas trees in the "boot" of their car, which is British for "trunk." I rest my sad case. It's just weird that Flamingo Books did this�that's all. Where's the respect, the reverence, for the primal text?
Matt Babcock <BabcockM@Ricks.edu>
Rexburg, ID USA - Wednesday, August 18, 1999 at 17:50:47 (CDT)

Alert! Literary travesty in progress! "Northern Lights" was the only O'Brien I hadn't read yet; so I ordered it from Amazon.com.uk., and it came only two days later. Quick service, but after about an hour, I wondered what those limeys were up to. In short, Flamingo Books, a division of HarperCollins, changed all the American spellings to British: "kerb," "practising," "tyre," and so on. And I guess that didn't really bother me too much because I've spent some time in England, and it didn't break up the reading that much for me. But then on about page 35, when Harvey's coming home on the bus to Sawmill Landing, he starts complaining about the fact that there's no "bloody" parade to greet him and no "bloody" drinks from anyone.
Now, I'm not sure, but can what I'm thinking be true? Did this British publisher actually go through the text and change all the American epithets to British ones? Now, I ask you: is this right? Is this real? Is this reading? Would a young twenty-something Vietnam vet from some jerkwater alpine town in Minnesota in 1970 come home and start talking like he'd just stepped off the 12:10 Underground at St. Pancras? "I say, Gerald, there's a jolly load of napalm positively shredding the jungle this morning! I say, Jeeves, step lively with that M-16! That old chap Charlie's going to pop on over for tea this afternoon."
Sorry. But I had to go overboard to make my point. I can't really believe Flamingo Books did that; I mean, I'm glad to have in my hands a book I've been looking for for about five years, but still . . . I mean, don't we read to get that foreign experience, that lingo that makes us curious. Seriously, that's why we read, isn't it? To experience the strange, the old, the lost civilization, the painfully different?

So yeah. I guess I went a bit overboard, but I'm still stunned at what liberties this publishing company has taken. Every time I hear Harvey Perry swear, it's comical instead of real. It's a travesty, and should be stopped. Really, I'm an American, and I read Dickens for the foreign sound, for that wonderfully verbose 18th Century syntax that bounds all over the hills and dales�not so I can open up to the last chapter "A Christmas Carol" and hear Tiny Tim exclaim, "Dude, God bless us. Like everyone."
Matt Babcock <BabcockM@Ricks.edu>
Rexburg, ID USA - Friday, August 13, 1999 at 16:53:36 (CDT)

I seen an interview on tv that you were in talking of your books and experiences in nam. What I found most interesting was your explanation of how you turn your memories and imagination into literature. I am a beginning writer, and I found this very informative. Do you give seminars on your writing style?
Monique Murray <monuck@yahoo.com>
Moncton, NB Canada - Friday, August 13, 1999 at 12:48:52 (CDT)

Tim O'Brien is the great American writer! Where's that Pulitzer, huh? The Nobel? I'd like to know. Three greatest reading experiences of my life: 1. "On the Rainy River"�I was a substitute teacher at the Logan High School alternative campus in Logan, Utah�you know, for kids who smoke so much dope they'll flunk out unless the school district lends them a hand. Anyway, the teacher left me the assignment to have them read "On the Rainy River," which was reprinted in one of those special-for-classroom-use- only magazines. I can't remember the title. Anyway, the kids all refused�don't ask me why they were so tired; they'd already guzzled three Mountain Dews each for breakfast already�so I read it. Straight through. Even though I should've been cracking the old substitute teacher's whip. Amazing. Read "Things They Carried" later, of course.
2. "Going After Cacciato" as an undergrad at Utah State. Completely revamped my internal definitions of novelistic structure. Thank Prof. Bobbi Stearman for teaching it.
3. "In the Lake of the Woods"�I read this while sitting in a hammock on a lake in some woods! Lake Skaneatles in Skaneatles, New York. My father-in-law was puttering around down in the boathouse, wondering why I wouldn't get up and help him prime the motor on his boat. Well, I was busy! I had a good reason.
4. Sorry, top four reading experiences. "Tomcat in Love." Even though I was teaching a full load of comp and lit classes, and I was a brand new teacher, I had to read it. My wife bought it for my birthday. My classes suffered, I'm sure. I couldn't help it. Jane Smiley said it was a comic novel? Comic? No way! I ripped my guts out. Guess that's because I'm a guy.

I repeat: "Tim O'Brien is the great American writer! Over and out!"
Matt Babcock <BabcockM@Ricks.edu>
Rexburg, ID USA - Wednesday, August 04, 1999 at 17:15:42 (CDT)

Hi! I am a girl in South Africa who is in the process of joining the navy! I really enjoy your books! I read them and did a school book report based on three of them. "The things they carried", "If I die in a combat zone", and "Going after Cacciato" We were only allowed to choose three books or I would have been there forever...haha. I think your books are very thought-provoking. They left me thinking about them for days. I encourage everyone I know to read them. I remember the questions asked in the preface of you book "If I die in a combat zone". Questions that I believe will never have a conlusive answer. 'What does one think while walking through the jungle-afraid? Why do men go to war? Conscious decision? Fear of censure? Can it ever be right to fight a war one thinks is wrong? What is fear? What is courage-saying 'no' to a wrong war, or charging an enemy bunker or just enduring, hanging on, taking one step at a time? Who is brave and who is cowardly, and does it matter?' Does it matter? That is a good question! Or how about this? 'Men are killed, dead human beings are heavy and awkward to carry, things smell different in Vietnam,soldiers are afraid and often brave, drill sergeants are boors, some men think the war is proper and just and others don't, most don't care. Is that the stuff for a morality lesson, even for a theme? Do dreams offer lessons? Do nightmares have themes, do we awaken and analyze them and live our lives and advise others as a result? Can the foot soldier teach anything important about war, merely for having been there? I think not. He can tell war stories!' Tim...you must NEVER underestimate the lessons that are learned by you telling 'War Sories'. Andrea.
Andrea <sanavygirl@hotmail.com>
Cape Town, South Africa - Wednesday, August 04, 1999 at 14:21:49 (CDT)

Boys in green from your home town,
Fight a war of now renown,
Known as men of the C-Three-One
What ever the job, they got it done.

Life is measured by each day,
Scout for Charlie and the NVA:
Zap them fast and do not lag,
Their other choice is a body bag.

Live in jungle, sleep in marsh,
Learn to accept all that is harsh.
They understand their loss and fear,
And will to last for a "Big World" beer.

Total now all of their cost:
They won and came back--you say they lost.
(But in your hear, you'll always know:
You're not forgiven, You've lost your soul).
Jiggs Caudron <m1892@earthlink.net>
Walnut, CA USA - Sunday, August 01, 1999 at 14:34:14 (CDT)

Hi Tim ... I'll keep this simple ... Reading "The Things They Carried" was a memorable and true experience ... I have experienced near death and inconsolable loss of a loved one at close quarters (in an ocean undertow) ... The images in your book of death, sudden and close up, reside in my mind alongside my own experience ... Thank you for what must be extraordinary efforts at getting it right in the writing!
Jim Kennedy <James.Kennedy@ci.boston.ma.us>
Boston, MA USA - Saturday, July 31, 1999 at 13:06:18 (CDT)

I am the Americal Division Veteran's Association Historian. I have read and enjoyed several of your books. If you are ever interested in obtaining a copy of our historical data base on CD-ROM let me know. It includes all Americal Division Operational Reports and Lessons Learned, most Americal Division Publication, and 5/46th Inf historical summaries, as well as maps, and etc... Sincerely, Leslie Hines; 817 41st St. Des Moines, IA 50312-2609.
Leslie Hines <Pelican.123rd.avn@worldnet.att.net>
Des Moines, IA USA - Sunday, July 25, 1999 at 20:16:06 (CDT)

Dear Tim, I am reading The Things They Carried Again. It captures like no other book I've ever read the anguish of war. After having suffered what you did, you didn't allow it to go for naught/ you turned your experience into something that can heal others who were hurt like you were. I am your age; I spent time at harvard also; I struggled against the war in the US, then volunteered for a position in Africa to respond to what we were doing in Vietnam. Now I sometimes work with war vets, and I give them your book to read. I believe it helps. I hope you know that your experience is touching people everyday. I hope you never allow your anguish to win. You have been a great gift to many people. Thank you for writing, and surviving. Carol
carol inouye <rinouye@ibm.net>
yakima, wa USA - Sunday, July 25, 1999 at 18:42:49 (CDT)

I have read "Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong" and it has enlightened me as to the happenings and the possibilities of the effects that war has on individuals. I must confess that I would not have read it if it weren't an assignment for my composition class in college. It definitely made me want to read the book in its entirety.
Annette <brw@netins.net>
West Liberty, IA USA - Saturday, July 17, 1999 at 18:39:57 (CDT)

Tim I READ PART OF ONE OF YOUR BOOKS, AND THOUGHT THAT WHAT YOU WROTE REALLY WAS TRUE!! I TOO SERVED IN VIETNAM, WITH CHARLIE CO. 5/46TH 69-70, AND STILL REMEMBER GATOR AND THE BATANANG AREA WERE MY LAI WAS. JUST KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK SO THAT NO ONE FORGETS US GRUNTS!! IF ANY ONE WANTS TO WRITE ME THEY CAN AT KUNIKMICHAEL@YAHOO.COM THANKS LOADS.
michael kunik <kunikmichael@yahoo.com>
sheridan, wy USA - Saturday, July 17, 1999 at 11:43:37 (CDT)

Tim found you through Dusty's Poetry...and am responding to ON THE RAINY RIVER...this story has caught my emotions like no other...I have shared it aloud to a couple of people (one of them Canadian) and cried each time...the intensity is still with me weeks after reading. Thank you for sharing that portion of the Vietnam experience with me. Stanley Sabre USAF 64-68
Stanley Sabre <reshastanley@hotmail.com>
Seattle, WA USA - Thursday, July 15, 1999 at 09:18:46 (CDT)

Have signed already,but figured I check in again. Had some interesting correspondence with other O'brien fans because of this guestbook. I love Tim O'brien's work,and have read everything but Tomcat In Love, and nuclear age. I would love to hear from other fans, and their opinions on Tim's work.
Emmet <Bestdurk@aol.com>
nyc, ny USA - Monday, July 12, 1999 at 14:55:45 (CDT)

Medic 1968-1970
David Dill <ddsd.gte.net>
Martinsville, IL USA - Friday, July 09, 1999 at 13:03:57 (CDT)

Enthralled by the superimposition of concealment in marriage, childhood baggage, immorality of war & politics!
Jelena <ebolton@eisa.net.au>
Australia - Friday, July 09, 1999 at 05:17:12 (CDT)

We are reading one of you war stories in class. "The Things They Carried" We like your stories.
Christine Herrera <Ecbth@aol.com>
Austin, tx USA - Thursday, July 08, 1999 at 16:13:10 (CDT)

Dear Mr. OBrien, I have reda almost all of your books, and Am resently half way through Tomcat in Love. I have only three authors I have read all of their work: Ernest HEmingway, JD Salinger and Tim OBrien. I wish to one day become a great author just like you. I also always wanted to meet my favorite authors...well Hemingway is out of the question (terminated his life way before I was even born)- JD Salinger (Well-who has actually seen the guy...I do wish he would publish new works) so the only one I do have a chance on meeting is you Mr. OBrien soI would like to know the next time you will be In a Los Angeles spot...doing some readings or whatever. Please let me know. Thanks. email screwball80@hotmail.com
Hector M. <screwball80@hotmail.com>
USA - Tuesday, July 06, 1999 at 23:16:10 (CDT)

Dear Mr. O'Brien - My father never told me anything of his time in Vietnam (he never talked to anyone about it) and before I understood enough to ask he had passed away. Even as a child I had senced how big a part of him that war was - the nightmares he'd wake up from, the slang he used, the halucination he had in the woods while hunting with me one day.... Thank you for bringing parts of my father back to life for me with "The Things They Carried". Your book was borrowed to me by a Vet. but shortly after he gave it to me he died. I have read this book in honor of my father and this Vet. I can't remember his name - only that he looked like my father and that he had the same indefinable inner chaos. "Speaking of Courage" helped make some sence of that chaos. I would like to tell you a little more about this "unnamed" vet. There are some more details about him and our time together that I believe you could use to make a great story. Thank You so much for your gift of my father and please email me - I won't take much of your time. A. Schultz
Aaron Schultz <as_traveler@hotmail.com>
St. Paul, MN USA - Monday, July 05, 1999 at 23:30:21 (CDT)

Hi Tim, Halfway through Tomcat in Love and I am loving it! This is the first book of yours I have read, but I am going to backtrack and read them all. Wonderfully witty and intelligent, each page is a joy to read. The line "I had the virility of Secretariat" made me howl. I am going to recommend you to all my reading friends, glad I found you... Thanks, Mike
Mike McFadden <Mikemcf31@yahoo.com>
Emerson, NJ USA - Saturday, July 03, 1999 at 00:06:08 (CDT)

Tim, Second post to your guestbook. Finished "TOM CAT" on the plane on the way home from the Americal Reunion in St. Louis. Great book! Met a few guys from Alpha 5/46th you may have served with in 1969-70 on LZ Gator? My C/5/46 group had twenty show up that all served together in 1970-71. We had a few published authors show up that were grunts for a book signing. Would love for you to make the next reunion in San Antonio? As with most of your messages, "The Things They (WE) Carried," is my favorite read. That's the way it was. Take Care, Dave Hammond
Dave Hammond <Hammond@ipinc.net>
Beaverton, OR USA - Thursday, June 24, 1999 at 17:04:17 (CDT)

I have recently read your short story, "The Things They Carried", and liked it very much. I know you served in Vietnam from reading a short bio on you, and I was wondering what drove you to write this particular story. Was the story based entirely on your experiences in Vietnam? What did you carry in Vietnam that compelled you to write such a moving story? At any rate, I loved the story and I am looking forward to reading more of your work. Thanks. Jimmy
James Finnerty <angelica64@postoffice.worldnet.att.net>
Bayside, NY USA - Thursday, June 17, 1999 at 21:50:47 (CDT)

I thought the wweb page was wonderful. I am doing a research project on Tim O'Brien, and everything I find out shows me how much more interesting that he is. If anyone has any information they would be willing to share, I would love to hear from you!
Lyn <LynnyAngel@aol.com>
Greenville, NC USA - Wednesday, June 09, 1999 at 14:29:21 (CDT)

I was a line-platooner with the 11th LIB. completed an 107 page, soft cover, self written & published book on true accounts and occurances: THE C-3/1 PAPERS by Jiggs Caudron....take a peek, there are some parallels here.
Jiggs Caudron <m1892@earthlink.net>
Walnut, CA USA - Tuesday, June 08, 1999 at 23:05:35 (CDT)

I am 13 years old. I read the book "The Things They Carried" for 8th grade english. Tomarrow I am having an exam and I recived the essay in advanced to get ideas before hand. I need to wright of a hero in the book. I was thinking of heros who weren't very straight forward like stories or Martha. I don't know what I should do. I hope to read more of your books.
William Kelley <williamthewild@earthlink.com>
Falls Church, va USA - Thursday, June 03, 1999 at 19:03:53 (CDT)

mr o'brien I sign your guest book in the name of my son, wo-1 george william pepe who gave his life in a dirty, brutal war so that others might protest our involvement.
william george pepe <billpepe@webtv.net>
hampstead, nc USA - Monday, May 31, 1999 at 17:39:19 (CDT)

Great Site! Please visit mine.
A Year To Kill <vietnam67@worldnet.att.net>
USA - Friday, May 28, 1999 at 01:50:13 (CDT)

The Things They Carried, ultamitely true to its truths, is by far the best book I have read since To Kill A Mockingbird. I read it as required reading in the 11th grade, and couldn't put it down. I insisted my teacher let me read If I Die in a Combat Zone next, for credit. Never have I known an author to so greatly visualize, disect, and describe the real world, inside and outside of our minds.
Casey Jepson
Seattle, WA USA - Friday, May 28, 1999 at 00:58:40 (CDT)

O'Brien A little over a year ago I began to read some of the conflict that America was involved in. Your book was the first one and it got me started on a whirl wind tour of almost a year reading other books on the subject. As a REMF from '68-70 I must say that I enjoyed the first more than any.I felt that it conveyed the war as the grunt saw it. Super Job. As a mail clerk in those years I had a lot of opportunity to converse with those who wanted to talk and your book I think really does a good job of telling about the war through the eyes of an every day garden variety soldier. Those were confusing times in this country and I think it has yet overcome the injustices that was bestowed on the American GI at that time. It seems as if the country keeps trying to get it right but somehow cannot make up for it. Anyway my opinion does not mean a thing. I thought your book was super.
Frankie Howell <Sapony Crk>
Nashville, N.C. USA - Thursday, May 27, 1999 at 16:45:53 (CDT)

Spent time in the Batangan off and on in 7 campaign periods as a 0311/dirt Grunt. I call the place "The Meanest Place on Earth". Tim has made sure history will reflect this area- as such. Thx Tim
CWO Ed NICHOLLS USMC/USArmy Ret. <sgtnick@gvtc.com>
Kendalia, TX USA - Wednesday, May 26, 1999 at 02:46:13 (CDT)

Dear Mr O'Brien or any one else out their who may be able to help me, I cant say that I've read any of your books but I am caputured by the premise of "going after Caciatto". The problem I am having you see is finding a bloody copy of the thing! Someone tell me where to go, all my local book shops say its out of print, Help please.
Damien Ward <damienward@hotmail.com>
Lismore, Nnnsw Australia - Monday, May 24, 1999 at 23:04:43 (CDT)

Dear Mr. o'Brien, I sincerely address an act of honor towards you for the talented piece of literature that our Junior class at James Logan High have read. The book, The Things They Carried, is an inspirational story which you have let remain alive. There are many unforgettable passages in the book which brings out the importance of life and death, and gives the reader sympathetic feelings towards the soldiers and heroes of our country. I have not known until I have reached the end, how war can truly bring out the uniqueness of an individual which also stresses the weaknesses and strengths that one posses and endures. To be honest as a student, this book has taken my full attention compared to some other works that we have read. I can show no less than respect towards your story well put together, as well as you for the courage that remains in you. Thank you for teaching me many values that would be important for me to grow into a mature adult.
Andrea Festejo <jahbootie38@juno.com>
Union City, Ca USA - Saturday, May 22, 1999 at 19:59:18 (CDT)

"The Things They Carried" should be required reading for every American... I can't wait to read his other books. God bless him!
Doug Girard <douggirard@aol.com>
Trumbull, CT USA - Thursday, May 20, 1999 at 12:56:27 (CDT)

Howdy!umm...i have a question...i think my english teacher told me this but umm...i think she said that you don't talk about your experience in Vietnam you write about it...Do you have trouble talking to people about your experience?i mean don't get me wrong...your book is really cool...but i was just curious well okay...bye
Yohana Del Rosario <Sillyhana@hotmail.com>
Daly City, CA USA - Tuesday, May 18, 1999 at 21:33:06 (CDT)

Hi! It's songtrabong again, I wrote once before, but I just finished reading In the Lake of the Woods and wanted to throw some more praise your way. Although The Things They Carried still has its claws in my gut in a way I've never experienced before. Anyway, I can't think of a better way to give you praise than by letting you know how much your work inspires me. I just finished writing a story with the tentative title In the Layers of Brick Over Earth. Well the point is, it's the first story in a slew of beginnings that finally found an end, and I wrote the whole thing about a week after finishing In the Lake of the Woods. So thanks, whether intended or not, for the encouragement. I read so much these days, and it's all encouraging. There are so many great authors out there, even if I could not join them, I'd be happy just knowing they were out there somewhere still writing. Which brings up a question I had: does anyone ever recommend a good read to you? If you haven't yet, I strongly recommend Faulkner's As I Lay Dying or George Orwell's A Clergyman's Daughter, both sad, beautiful, honest novels. Having taken up entirely too much space, I'll sign off saying once again (and as I'm sure you're all to familiar hearing though definately deserving) thanks. Anna. P. S. Did someone actually say you'd written a true war story with The Things They Carried? That boggles my mind; where in life is there actually any truth?
Anna Hirsch <songtrabong@yahoo.com>
Kirksville, MO USA - Tuesday, May 18, 1999 at 18:32:39 (CDT)

I didn't go to the website; I just felt like signing this book.
Heather Smith
USA - Monday, May 17, 1999 at 21:12:07 (CDT)

Dear Mr. O'Brien. I address you as Mr. O'Brien not to seem impersonal, but rather out of deep respect. Because now, after reading your book, The Things they Carried, I have so much respect for you. When my Junior english class first began reading it, I had no idea what I was about to embark on. Your stories have so much meaning to them, not just what's on the surface; and that's one of the things that I liked about the book. What a great writer you are. You really do tell a true war story. I really got to konw the characters, or shall I say people, as well as you. I felt the agony and sorrow the soldiers did as each special human being died. I only hope that by writting this book, it has eased some of your pain, and put your mind to rest. I wish that there was something I could say that would help soften the scars of war, but I know that there is nothing anyone can say. And so, I am writting this to you to show my appreciation and let you know that you have a talent, and are using it well. Thank you.
Rebekah Yorke <bekahy@hotmail.com>
Hayward, Ca USA - Monday, May 17, 1999 at 19:53:05 (CDT)

I loved your book The Things They Carried. Usually I never read books, but after your first section of the book I couldn't put it down. It made me feel like I was really there.
Tyler Nimmer <ronnimmer@juno.com>
Reno, NV USA - Sunday, May 16, 1999 at 23:48:58 (CDT)

Mr. O'brien, I am a sophmore in highschool and we are currently reading your inspirational novel in our class. My teacher presented us with the challenge of locating you, and requesting your presence at our school to speak with my fellow students about your excellent books. So far I have enjoyed the book and am very close to finishing it. Your descriptions of Vietnam, and the way you present the stories are absolutley astounding! I am a gracious reader, and enjoy this book a great deal. Please consider our request and respond. Your response, and perhaps your presence will be greatly appreciated. Sincerely- an avid reader - Shannon
Shannon <slr01923@aol.com>
Danvers, Ma USA - Thursday, May 13, 1999 at 16:17:23 (CDT)

Hello Mr. O'Brien: I am a high school student in Melbourne (Australia), we are currently studying your book 'in the lake of the woods' for English. I enjoyed your book very much but there are bits and pieces where I don't understand. Would you please send me an e-mail and give me a few hints on the book? Please! And can you also tell me what you think happened to Kathy. (personally I think Kathy just had enough of John Wade and left him). My e-mail is sykes00@hotmail.com My name is Andrew Ma Thank you.
Andrew Ma <sykes00@hotmail.com>
Melbourne, Vic Australia - Wednesday, May 12, 1999 at 20:13:15 (CDT)

Mr. O'brien. I am not sure how often you read these comments. I would like you to respond to a line in "Going After Cacciato" that I found very curious. It concerns the private life of Paul Berlin and Sarkin Aung Wan. I have a theory that Paul returns to this part of the fantasy at a later time when he is not marching with the rest of the soldiers. There is an interview in the book "Nam" by Mark Baker that I think backs up my theory. I like the idea inhereht in the novel that imagination is one of the possible means for coping with the day to day horror, death, and at times, dullness of war. "Going After Cacciato" is one of my favorite novels. I love discussing it every chance I get. I look forward to a response. Thank you.
Will <wdgators@aol.com>
austin, tx USA - Tuesday, May 11, 1999 at 20:03:07 (CDT)

Mr. O'Brien. Starting a new unit here at Concordia H.S. about Vietnam just isn't complete without your words. You "show" us Vietnam and give my students, many of whom had parents fight with you, a true idea of what happened. If you have any essay suggestions they would be appreciated.
Robert Goff <goffnkansas@hotmail.com>
Concordia, KS USA - Monday, May 10, 1999 at 21:18:46 (CDT)

I just spent 20 minutes looking for my copy of "Going After C." because I couldn't remember the author!!! One short search in Yahoo....here it is!!! Great work...will always be with me. BTW, could Tim send me a 10 page outline for my literary thesis due next Wednesday...some little hints, ideas?? (just kidding..A!) Good luck... Pat Lueck.....
Patrick J Lueck <pjlueck@bitstream.net>
Eden Prairie, MN USA - Sunday, May 09, 1999 at 01:15:14 (CDT)

I recentley had to read your book for my English class and became utterly engrossed in it. It took me two days to finish what we had alloted a month for. My parents would find me up at odd hours of the night because I just couldn't put the book down. I loved it. I would just like to say thank you for writing such a moving and compelling novel. I hope you continue to write more stories. Thank you.
Tom Vandevoordt <schnoozen@juno.com>
Monroe, CT USA - Saturday, May 08, 1999 at 19:38:18 (CDT)

I would love to be sent a copy of your latest book for my aunt. I love your works and find you are the only book i have ever read in school which i enjoyed. The reason i read this was because of my aunt. She loves your work and teaches your books every year. I only have one question. Was "The Things They Carried" a true story.
Brain Hart <Kinglooper@yahoo.com>
Elk Grove, ca USA - Saturday, May 08, 1999 at 15:49:04 (CDT)

I read "The Things They Carried" for Literature of Vietnam, a class I took. The character development is wonderful, the most sympathetic people become killers, during this horrible American tragedy, Vietnam.
Tara Hoffman <ltnf@iup.edu>
Indiana, Pa USA - Friday, May 07, 1999 at 14:27:32 (CDT)

I am reading your book-"The Things They Carried" for english and I just want to say that I think you are a great writer. I love how you describe the war and all the people. It's nice to read a war book that isn't glorified or horrified. All the people and stories just come alive. You are a great man and I hope that will continue to write more great stories!
julie <julie_coconut@yahoo.com>
kuna, ID USA - Wednesday, May 05, 1999 at 14:17:37 (CDT)

My modern war in fiction writing class I took at Bettendorf high school was taught by John Levelle who was a veitnam vet. He would pass out writtings from Tim O'brien for us to read and get ideals from for our own stories. Once he told us a story about when he had met Mr. O'brien in a bar somewhere and they bullshitted for awhile. he had told us that he had out drank O'brein.
Jonah Dau <JonahDAU@aol.com>
Davenport, IA USA - Tuesday, May 04, 1999 at 21:14:12 (CDT)

I'm currently writing a report on you, and would greatly appreciate some background information on you. If you have the time, please e-mail me. Thank you.
Francis Smith <francismsmith@hotmail.com>
Angleton, TX USA - Tuesday, May 04, 1999 at 14:26:47 (CDT)

writing a paper comparing tim's "the things they carried" and crane's "the red badge of courage." any suggestions?
edith <ediesedg@maine.rr.com>
USA - Tuesday, May 04, 1999 at 13:54:58 (CDT)

Tim, I read your book on The Things They Carried. It is required in my English A class and I was so interested how you wrote the book and the book is very visteral. Excuse my spelling due to my deafness. Now I am thinking about write my essay about you and I hope I ace it. Thank you for open my eyes about the war. My dad was in the service during Peral Harbor and my father-in-law was in Koerea. So, now I kind of understand them better after reading your book. Once again Thank you. Sharon
Sharon Cotter <sdcotter@hotmail.com>
Merced, CA USA - Saturday, May 01, 1999 at 23:20:15 (CDT)

Dear Mr. O'Brien, I have just finished your book, The Things They Carried, and I felt I had to write you to thank you for such a rich and meaningful work on Vietnam. I have read the other entries in your "guest book," and I feel that I may be repeating things that have written, but it is important to me that you know how much your work meant to me. My father was killed in Vietnam when I was only three years old, but I have always been searching for someone to tell me something of what it was like over there so that I would understand why he died. Although I never really knew him, I am always reminded of him through people who knew him. Your stories did more for me to understand the craziness than any research I have done. I don't know if you will ever read this, but if you do, please keep the stories coming. I am eager to read your other novels and short stories. Thank you again for your honesty and artistry.
Lalla Dabbs
Charlotte, NC USA - Friday, April 30, 1999 at 21:49:30 (CDT)

Tim, I picked up The Things They Carried this week. I can't put it down. Your books always get to me. Thanks for sharing your stories.
Shawn Rubsam Moore <moore@fishnet.com>
Minneapolis, MN USA - Friday, April 30, 1999 at 13:32:43 (CDT)

I recently read "The Things They Carried" and was deeply moved. Being from that era, nearly 46 yrs. old, I was able to appreciate the how difficult it must have been for you. I look forward to reading more of your fine works are you are an exceptional writer. Thanks
Alan Beausoleil <ablbsp>
USA - Friday, April 30, 1999 at 12:44:03 (CDT)

Tim O'Brien rules!
Kevin Clearkin
Maple Glen, PA USA - Thursday, April 29, 1999 at 09:02:39 (CDT)

As I sit here writing this I have to wonder if you actually read all of these messages, my God, there must be hundreds! I'm sure I sort of look like a goofball too with an email adress like songtrabong (actually, I tried mockingbird first, but it was already taken). Anyway, I find myself coming back, again and again, to one particular line in The Things They Carried: But this too is true; stories can save us. From the time I was five or six years old I've had pen in my hand and paper to write on. I think I survived adolescence by writing. But really, I'm only now eighteen years old and on my way to the University of Chicago (I turned down Carleton and Macalester)--point being, I'm sure I still have a lot of rescuing to do, i. e. a lot of writing to do. Anyway, what I had meant to say in what has become a frighting long-winded way was thank you. I'm sure you hear that quite often, but for whatever its worth, thankyou. The only book I ever cried over was Jean M. Aeul's Clan of the Cave Bear, the only book I ever felt shaken by was Zora Neale Hurston's, Their Eyes Were Watching God, and the only book that ever made me feel whole was The Things They Carried. God, I must have crazy dreams to write anything as beautiful as any of these authors, but your words give me all the inspiration I need to keep on trying. So again, thank you. Yours truly, Anna.
Anna Hirsch <songtrabong@yahoo.com>
Kirksville, MO USA - Wednesday, April 28, 1999 at 20:41:41 (CDT)

My previous message had an incorrect return address. This is the right one: garethshef@aol.com
Gareth <Garethshef@aol.com>
USA - Wednesday, April 28, 1999 at 17:16:14 (CDT)

Dear Mr O'Brien, I met you recently when you visited Leeds as part of your UK tour. It was a pleasure and a privilege. Thankyou for your time, reading from Tomcat In Love and discussing your life and work. I hope we meet again one day. Congratulations on 'Tomcat', a wonderful book full of insight and emotions. Gareth Johnstone
Gareth Johnstone <gaethshef@aol.com>
Sheffield, UK - Wednesday, April 28, 1999 at 17:13:33 (CDT)

tim i love ur wirting in "On the rainy river" your symbloism is fantastic and i enjoyed reading it. u paont such a vivid picture for the reader. we only went over it in class for a day but this was a story that i was really interested in analyzing more. very intriguing work u do thanks a lot for making at least one english class fun for me
becca <onecatch32@aol.com>
fred, va USA - Tuesday, April 27, 1999 at 22:00:39 (CDT)

Tim, Your work was introduced to me in 1994 at the University of Dayton in a literature class on the Vietnem War. I am currently reading In the Lake of the Woods and have also shared your work with several freinds who've developed their own appreciation. I've hatched from campus and have found a career at Bretford Manufacturing, a library furniture company. On behalf of Bretford, I would like to invite you to be our guest at the 1999 American Library Association Conference in New Orleans, Louisiana. The conference runs from June 26-29. It would be an honor to support your work and share it with thousands of librarians and educators. Please respond. Thanks.
Matt Petrick <hamneggs@compuserve.com>
Oak Park , IL USA - Monday, April 26, 1999 at 12:56:33 (CDT)

I am currently in a Minnesota Authors class and I have been doing some research on you for a paper. I just want to let you know that I truly enjoy your books and your insight and knowledge about the Vietnam war and how you put it into your'e writing. Your'e books are awesome!
Kristin Showalter <vicky@hutchtel.net>
Hutchinson, MN USA - Sunday, April 25, 1999 at 17:51:50 (CDT)

I am a senior at a private school and I am in the middle of a 3 month long independent study on Tim O'Brien. I have read "The Things They Carried" which is one of the best, most moving books I've read so far. I am now in the middle of "In The Lake of The Woods" and I love that one too. The teacher I am working with is a huge fan of O'Brien, and I have also been talking to another teacher at school, Peter Scott, who is friends with O'Brien. I have learned more than I thought posible, and enjoyed doing so, about the Vietnam War through "The Things..." and I feel that this site is helpful to my studies.
Allison Thomas <AMCT99@aol.com>
Cleveland, OH USA - Sunday, April 25, 1999 at 13:37:22 (CDT)

I'm a second semester student attending the University of Connecticut @ Storrs, CT, and I just stumbled upon this site. I have just finished reading "The Things They Carried" for my English class. Your vivid desciptions reveal a part of life that I hope I never have to experience. Excellent book, a story well told.
Michael Schmitt <mike@engr.uconn.edu>
Wilton, CCCCT USA - Sunday, April 25, 1999 at 01:20:05 (CDT)

Mr. O'Brien: I just finished your book "The Things They Carried" and felt the need to write you and thank you. I am a former US Marine but never served in combat. I have often wondered what it is/was like for servicemen who have been through that type of trial. Many times my service to the country seemed confusing, almost pointless, as I did my duty. I am glad that I served, but often wondered what the point was -- as I still do. There were times I wanted the "honor" of serving in combat, and other times I thanked God for keeping me from that -- I was scared to death of the thought of fighting and having to kill or be killed. I am grateful for not having had to do that. This book really helped me to understand not only what you and your comrades felt, but that my being thankful is not wrong. Thank you for sharing your experiences, and thank God for keeping you and yours safe. Semper Fidelis.
Curtis B. Long <howie@iastate.edu>
Ankeny, IA USA - Sunday, April 25, 1999 at 00:21:28 (CDT)

I am a great fan of your work.Thank you for giving us a thoughtful,honest view of the emotional struggles you endured before leaving for Vietnam, as well as what you had over there.Cacciato is a masterpiece, and my favorite piece of literature to date.I love the character Paul Berlin.Reading your books has given me a much deeper appreciation of veterans of wars, from both sides. We are all just human.Thank you for pointing that out.
Emmet Macken <Bestdurk@aol.com>
New York City, ny USA - Saturday, April 24, 1999 at 00:53:35 (CDT)

Mr. O'Brien- My name is Ryan and I am in Dr.Norris's, Dale Norris, english class here at the community college in DesMoines. "The Things They Carried", alot of people have read it, I wonder how many people really feel it. What I want to ask, if you even read these things, concerns the political statement you make in the book. Is the "point" simply to make the reader feel the ambiguity of the war, how a 20 year old kid feels the ambiguity and then twenty years later how he reinvents, rehappens the past and the memories, reshapes them into story truths that become truer than truth to try to make sense out of a time and place that the soldier was in but never saw. Or is there a solid socio-cultural statement your making here about what America does to its kids. I am torn, hanging out in the thick fog over this.
Ryan Johnson <Gjohn61446@aol.com>
DesMoines, Ia USA - Saturday, April 24, 1999 at 00:30:45 (CDT)

I must start by saying that I was not familiar with you as an author. I was searching the Web on info about My Lai after watching an old episode of Frontline. It was while doing the search that I noticed your name and thought that I had seen it as someone who had been interviewed for the documentary 'The Ten Thousand Day War'. I will now have to try to obtain one of your books.
Kevin Perry <kevper@nb.sympatico.ca>
Rothesay, NB Canada - Saturday, March 13, 1999 at 13:01:42 (CST)

Tim, I enjoyed hearing you at the DMA in Dallas March 11. CACCIATO was the first book I read on my Viet-Nam journal in 1980. I started writing in 84 about my years in Sai-Gon 68-70. I was married to Jon Merkel who was a chopper pilot for Air America. Jon was killed 18 Feb 70 flying in Laos. His death was reported in the NYTIMES: First Casulty Plain of Jars. I was instructed not to talk to anyone about his death. So I wrote about it instead. I'll glad you're coming to Austin for the 99 school year at San Marcus. I'll try to start the paperwork and submit your name as a Fellow to lecture for two days at the girls' school where I teach in Dallas. Enjoyed your comment about your daughter; it encourages me to hear someone else who functions easily with poetic license. Take care, k
Kay Merkel Boruff <kboruff@mail.hockaday.org>
Dallas, TX USA - Friday, March 12, 1999 at 15:27:17 (CST)

tim, our english class has just finished reading 'in the lake of the woods'. we found your book wonderfully challenging and lyrical, despite the questions it left us with. congratulaions on this successfully chilling novel! perhaps one day we will have the privelidge of having you read some of our work. all the best, sarah and nessa.
Nessa and Sarah <CparKLZ@hotmail.com>
melbourne, VIC Australia - Wednesday, March 10, 1999 at 17:30:40 (CST)

Sir, the first time I have heard about you is this year in my higschool english class. We read the first chapter of The Things They Carried and well I liked so much that that day I went to our school's library after class and checked it out. I am almost finished and I will read another one of your books. I am planning on enlisting into the service and this book has help give me a little insight to what I might face of course I will never truly know unless I experience it myself.Thankyou and have a good day.
Christopher Young <Rebrayder@hotmail.com>
New Orleans, La USA - Sunday, March 07, 1999 at 21:56:42 (CST)

Hi Mr. O'Brien, I'm a sophomore at the University of Hartford doing a comparison of your excerpt in "The Vintage Book of Contemporary American Short Stories" (ed. Tobias Wolff)(an excerpt from "The Things they carried") with the Jamaica Kincaid short story "Girl" and I want to make a comparison on "how to be a man" in your excerpt with Kincaid's list of "how to be a woman" in the story. I found your story completely fascinating in a really humanistic sense, and got an A on a paper I wrote doing a "reading" on it. The story really moved me...enough, in fact, to read the book once mid-terms are over...thanks, beth
Elizabeth Guerriero <guerriero@mail.hartford.edu>
Hartford, CT USA - Friday, March 05, 1999 at 18:41:38 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien, I was first introduced to your work while I attended Emerson College and studied under Prof. Henry. You fiction in an important part of my life, both as a person and as a writer. Rather than saying what an important writer you are and telling you why I think so, I'd rather thank you for putting out the kind of stories which challenge the way we understand ourselves and point at the kind of people we may be.
chris <cbalzano@acad.suffolk.edu>
Boston, ma USA - Friday, March 05, 1999 at 11:00:46 (CST)

I am a high school teacher of English 11 and Advanced Placement English 11. In both classes we have read TheThings They Carried during the past few years. My students overwhelmingly enjoy your book more than any other novels we read. I use your writing as examples when we cover style analysis. Even though I have read passages over and over in this book, I never fail to be struck by the emotional content and powerful style you exhibit. In "The Lives of the Dead" (a wonderful title), I read this chapter aloud with the students. We all feel the impact of such vivid imagery. My students would be bowled over if you would e-mail them. But we would understand that you are a busy person and may not have time. Thank you for the gift you've given us by writing The Things They Carried. Kim Fitzsimmons, English teacher at Roswell High School (Yes, home of the alien crash site)
Kim Fitzsimmons <kkfitzy@hotmail.com>
Roswell, NM USA - Thursday, March 04, 1999 at 16:33:42 (CST)

I have a question about copyright infringement that I believe you can answer for me. I plan on using The Things They Carried in a course I am teaching in the Virtual High School for the 1999-2000 school year and hopefully beyond. In the course, I will ask students to respond to five passages from your novel which will be posted at the Virtual High School and accessible only by registered students. While it would seem to me no different than typing the passage on a sheet of paper and handing it out in class, the Internet raises issues that are different. May I do so? Thanks.
Thomas Redding <tredding@neo.lrun.com>
Akron, OH USA - Wednesday, March 03, 1999 at 09:25:49 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien- I am a senior at Princeton University and a tremendous admirer of your work. I am currently writing my senior thesis on author Ambrose Bierce. I have noticed a tremendous amount of similarities between you and Bierce, to which I will devote a chapter of the thesis. I would love any information or to discuss these aspects of your work at any time in the near future.
Laura Godfrey <lgodfrey@princeton.edu>
Princeton, NJ USA - Friday, February 26, 1999 at 23:38:03 (CST)

Dear Mr.O'Brien, Ihave been trying to get in contact with you so long. Last year i speended a schoolyear in the United States, Michigan. I went to high school to learn the language and to get to know the american culture. So in school one of the teachers told me to read your book The things they carried and at first I wasn't to thrilled I have to say, reading an english book, I had never done it before... But when I started reading I couldn't put it away, it was the best book I ever read!! Well anyway I went back home, but I couldn't stop thinking of the book I read in America so I started to search for it in bookstores here in Sweden but I couln't find it anywhere. Instead I have been reading a lot of other books about the Vietnam war and getting really interested of it. How could it happen? A few weeks ago I finally found the book I had been looking for, but in Swedish....(Allt de bar). I have now read it, but I would like to ask: How can I find your book in English here in Sweden??? I would be so happy if you could help me. Thank you for taking your time. You can write me at: dialog@ethel.se
Linda Ekstrand <None right now...>
Stockholm, - SWEDEN - Wednesday, February 24, 1999 at 08:49:07 (CST)

I had the priviledge of reading your book, "The Things They Carried" for my my Compostion class this spring semester. I was greatly moved by your writing and it makes me look at Vietnam differently. I have seen videos that were made by Vets and they were not legally made and dispered as they were supposed to, but it got the point across. I found it hard to look at all the pictures of the men that were wounded in battle in the ER scenes. I wanted to tell you that your books are great and really enlighten people about Vietnam. I know that my class thought that your book was great and that it really made that look and feel what exactly happened. Thanks and God Bless
Traci Grabitske <tmgrabitske@mail.viterbo.edu>
LaCrosse, WI USA - Tuesday, February 23, 1999 at 18:00:47 (CST)

Hi I read your book "The Things They Carried". I injoyed the book very much. I have to do a research paper on that book now and I wondered If you could give me some Info about it. Thanks Brett Bauer
Brett Bauer <Cgoltl@esu15.esu15.k12.ne.us>
Culbertson, Ne USA - Tuesday, February 23, 1999 at 08:56:21 (CST)

Hi Tim, Read your Home Page and enjoyed it very much. I have your book "If I Die In a Combat Zone" and enjoyed it very much. We both are from a small town in Minnesota, and, I believe the same town. I lived in Cohasset and a family of O'Briens lived right across the street from us, next to the softball/baseball field. The O'Brien children us to play with us "Cramers" and we all went to school together. You were quite a bit younger, so that left you out. I was in the Air Force, administrative field, and I was stationed at MACV J4 for 18 months and worked for the Pacification Branch under Logistics with the USAID/Air America persons. Was there Oct 69 to May 71.
Barbara (Bobbie) Cramer <jerbac@aol.com>
Lawndale, Ca USA - Sunday, February 21, 1999 at 23:53:05 (CST)

I just wanted to say that I read The Things They Carried and I found it to be one of the most brilliant pieces of literature I have ever read.
Steven Maiullo <Laocoon5@aol.com>
Boston , MA USA - Thursday, February 18, 1999 at 09:03:55 (CST)

My uncle and grandfather served in Vietnam. The latter of the two did three tours. Both are so reserved now that it is hard, nearly impossible, to receive details about this far away place. Your stories have shown me the hell they were put through. I now understand they're silence. You are by far one of the greatest writers this country has ever given birth to. Thanks, Mr. O'Brien.
Jason McNeill <jmstickers52@hotmail.com>
Seven Lakes, NC USA - Tuesday, February 16, 1999 at 21:18:59 (CST)

Tim - I hear you're coming to Charleston next year. Looking forward to seeing you. Hope you can spend some time and maybe visit the USS Yorktown. James Gregory I Co, 3/7 USMC 69-70
James Gregory <jgregory@awod.com>
Charleston, Sc USA - Monday, February 15, 1999 at 16:57:19 (CST)

I'm another Tim O'Brien fan, Vietnam veteran, educator, parent, etc. Browsing the web on a quite holiday afternoon.
Jim Rothblatt <redleef@gte.net>
Palm Springs, CA USA - Monday, February 15, 1999 at 16:01:56 (CST)

I read your story How to Tell a True War Story in my English Comp II class at Casper College. I am a Desert Storm Vet and although we did not have to endure the trials my Nam counterparts did, the truths you brought out in this story span both generations and war types. I have since decided to do my author research paper on you and your stories. However I am having trouble finding significant information on your writing history and biography info to complete my paper. Any one out there with other websites or personal info please forward them to me. Tim, Thank You for the stories and the realizations that come with them.
Louise Younger <lyounger@coffey.com>
Casper, WY USA - Monday, February 15, 1999 at 12:02:40 (CST)

Can anyone tell me where to locate a prose poem version of "The Thingd They Carried"?
Melissa Young <jimysr41@flash.net>
Sterling Hgts, MI USA - Sunday, February 14, 1999 at 11:59:51 (CST)

I'm doing a thesis paper on the "Stockings" chapter in your book The Things They Carried. Is there any information about that chapter that you could give me to help me with my paper? I would greatly appreciate any information you could give me. Thanks
Kathy Long <knlong@cncacc.cn.edu>
Jefferson City, TN USA - Thursday, February 11, 1999 at 15:01:17 (CST)

I had incredible trouble getting our school board to approve "In the Lake" for my AP English class. The book has now been read by almost the whole town, even mentioned in Catholic priest's sermon. We would like for Tim O'Brien to speak at Alfred University next year. How can I submit that request? Thanks!
Kathryn Curl <kwcc@eznet.net>
Wellsville, NY USA - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 20:42:15 (CST)

Tim- I lost a father to Vietnam, not to say that he never returned from the war. His body surely did, but maybe not the whole man. As a child he used to tell me stories of this mysterious, terrible, and at times glorious place: Vietnam. My father has since gone to try to live his life at peace. For this I cannot blame him. I have read nearly all of you'r books and they have been nothing short of a life altering experiance for me. You'r words have given me some insight into this hell that stole my fathers soul, and helped me to accept that his excuses my hold some validity. Aside from the theraputic aspect that I have recived from you wrighting, I have also found it greatly moving. You have an untouchable ability to move the reader to great emotional planes. I have sobbed and laughed out loud for you'r words. As an aspireing wrighter myself, I deeply admire you, and you'r work. Keep on, we love it. Peace-Love-Harmony- Jenny Catlin, Bailey C.O.
Jenny Catlin
Bailey, C.O. USA - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 20:19:07 (CST)

I just read your story WHERE HAVE YOU GONE CHARMING BILLY. I truly enjoyed your story. I plan on reading some more stories. Thank you Mr.O'Brien
Veronica Ransom
Bamberg, SC USA - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 13:49:49 (CST)

i have been reading tims books for a high school project and i have enjoyed them. if anyone has any further information please send me stuff bout him--cool page.
jared <jmitkus@hotmail.com>
Damariscotta, Me USA - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 11:07:20 (CST)

I REALLY ENJOY YOUR BOOKS MR. O'BRIEN. IT REALLY TOUCHES MY HEART AND ALSO CATCHES MY ATTENTION WHEN I WAS READING IT SPECIAL FOR THE THINGS THEY CARRIED. THAT NOVEL WAS INCREDIBLE. I WOULD LOVE TO INTERVIEW MR.O'BRIEN ABOUT THE THINGST THEY CARRIED
jenny andre <juicy_j_79_98@yahoo.com>
USA - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 09:05:49 (CST)

I think with In the Lake of the Woods Mr. O�Brien has reached peak perfomance of contemporary writers. I am doing my senior thesis about the developement in the work of Tim O�Brien. I�d be very interested to disuss Mr. O�Brien�s work with other �fans�. A year ago I wrote a term paper about `The Road from Fact to Fiction� in In the Lake of the Woods and like to share my thoughts. Thank you for your amazing work Mr. O�Brien. Carsten Blatt P.S. It�s a pity that only one book (In the Lake...) is translated into german language and that one has a, in my opinion comletely misleading title. So keep pushing your publisher Mr. O�Brien - or I will translate or books.
Carsten Blatt <C.Blatt@t-online.de>
Hamburgt, Germany - Tuesday, February 09, 1999 at 05:27:53 (CST)

i read your story The Things They Carried. I thought it was great. I am currently writing a paper on it and was hoping if you got a chance you could give me some useful tips to include in on the paper.
Tanya Tucker <thestoner5@hotmail.com>
south holland, il USA - Tuesday, February 02, 1999 at 19:29:51 (CST)

I was fortunate enough to hear Tim O'Brien speak at my high school. He was amazing. Thanks Tim for coming to Maine and speaking to us about The Things They Carried.
Sasha Pelletier <Sasha13@usa.net>
Portland, ME USA - Tuesday, February 02, 1999 at 09:39:34 (CST)

Tim, another class of high school students has been profoundly affected by reading The Things They Carried! It would mean a great deal to those who wrote letters to you if their expressions of gratitude and comments about the impact of the book on their lives could reach your hands. Is there an address to which I may send these letters? A huge "thank you" to Kiowa, Jimmy, Tim, Linda, Henry, Norman, yes - Azar, and all the rest for they way they have enriched and forever changed us.
Barb Johnson <bhjohns@ties.k12.mn.us>
Plymouth, MN USA - Friday, January 29, 1999 at 21:31:43 (CST)

Tim, Thanks for the great stories. I was also with the 198th as a grunt. C/5/46, 198th, 70-71. Have you ever thought about joining the Americal Divisions Vets Association. We would love to have you on board. What unit were you with in the 198th? Take Care, Dave Hammond
Dave Hammond <Hammond@ipinc.net>
Beaverton, OR USA - Wednesday, January 27, 1999 at 22:28:51 (CST)

I am doing a research paper on Tim O'Brien. My english teacher assignd this to me. I have read "The Things They Carried" after reading this short stroy and many different articles, i have come to realize, that Tim O'Brien has an insight into the mind of an infantry man on the battlefield. While reading about him, and his works I have come to understand that war is not the glorious thing people would have you thnk that it is. Thank you Mr. O'Brien for showing the true sides of war and the effects that it can have.
Faith <Yippyskip2>
Irving, TX USA - Wednesday, January 27, 1999 at 19:11:04 (CST)

Tim I recently spoke to you at a "Tomcat in Love" reading at Barnes and Noble in Roseville, MN. I was at Mac the same time you were and served in Viet Nam in 68-69. I have recently moved to Grand Marais and host a radio program on our public radio station. I was wondering if I could interview you on the program? Please let me know or have someone let me know how I might make contact. Thanks so much. Bob Carter
Bob Carter <drydoc@gateway.net>
Grand Marais, MN USA - Thursday, January 21, 1999 at 20:37:45 (CST)

I have just finished reading THE THINGS THEY CARRIED. I just wanted to say the book was interesting. I have never been able to sit and read a book like I did with THE THINGS THEY CARRIED. Thanks for sharing your experiences with everybody.
C.Proa <www.RDPCRP.@aol.com>
San Antonio, Tx USA - Thursday, January 21, 1999 at 20:12:42 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien, Thank you for your book. We are studying it in my college prep course at the moment and I found it very moving. This is a great example of literature to be appreciated. Thank you once again.
Rebecca Leerhoff <mnrebel@hotmail.com>
Anoka, MN USA - Wednesday, January 20, 1999 at 20:18:32 (CST)

Mr. O'Brien, My age and relatively benign life experience cause me to feel inadequate to praise your books. I will, however, say thank you. I am studying to be a professor of American Lit. Until recently, I have had no specific focus. Since reading "The Things They Carried" in a creavtive writing class, I have been devouring Vietnam era fiction and non-fiction. I would like to teach this literature if possible, but I am a little confused as to how to go about finding a grad school that will allow me to study/teach Vietnam era literature. Can you help me? I would appreciate any comments and or suggestions. Thank you, sir. Angela
Angela Attie <angiecita@hotmail.com>
Columbus, OH USA - Tuesday, January 19, 1999 at 12:56:27 (CST)

I like your book.
Phil Tripodi <dmbwop99@hotmail.com>
USA - Monday, January 18, 1999 at 11:12:21 (CST)

I was a military wife during Vietnam. Now I am a college professor teaching The Things They Carried. Students sometimes don't know how to react to it, but they feel the underlying great truths nonetheless. In the Lake of the Woods is another I would like to have classes read. Anyone else teaching these books with comments to share? Thanks, Tim O'Brien. I have Tomcat and that's next.
Ellen Shull <EMSHULL@aol.com>
San Antonio, TX USA - Sunday, January 17, 1999 at 17:22:11 (CST)

Tom: Love your work. I too have written my memoirs [Infantry, 1970-71] and am working on a novel. While I do not presume to have your talent, others have told me that I should try publishing some of my work, but I don't know how. Would you recommend an honest agent or have any advice? Thanks in advance. Gary Capshaw
Gary Capshaw <kiteria@texoma.net>
Pottsboro, Tx USA - Thursday, January 14, 1999 at 23:17:15 (CST)

I am doing a research paper on one of your short stories "On the Rainy River" and I have enjoyed them thoroughly. Do you have any analysis the that story I can review?
Cleveland Lewis <planna@erols.com>
Bronx, NY USA - Wednesday, January 13, 1999 at 15:13:01 (CST)

Like nearly every other person on this website, I am an adoring fan of the works of Tim O'Brien. This might be the first paper I've enjoyed researching. I have been touched by his words and insights. Mr. O'Brien, I love your stories! Thank you. If you only knew how much it means.
Megan Ballinger <MeganBalli@aol.com>
Euclid, OH USA - Sunday, January 03, 1999 at 14:32:07 (CST)

I have just finished reading In the Lake of the Woods, having previously read The Things they Carried, and Going After Caciato. Began reading your work after writing fifth or sixth draft of our novel, Morning Calm (experiences of American soldier stationed in Korea during Vietnam War, sent on "illegal" missions to Cambodia--with orders not to discuss them for min. of 25 years.) After multiple rejections and rewrites, my collaborator and I are still (8 years and running), working to perfect a story that is very important to us. Your books inspire me to continue my struggle and help my partner focus with me on this, his most important, goal. Thanks for your insights. Karyn
Karyn Lewis Searcy <KARYNLS2@aol.com>
Imperial Beach, CA USA - Sunday, January 03, 1999 at 11:56:22 (CST)

Read the Previous Guest Book

Return to the Tim O'Brien's Home Page

Search WWW Search Illyria
Search Spencer Group Search Vietnam Veterans